get the one in the first pic you posted. He might not be a Magma, BUT with the double flower line, amazing red, and kok growth starting to show he could end up being a stunning fish.
Also somewhere i read that flowerhorns with white eyes are infertile, though i have no intention of breeding flowerhorns but doea it effects the general kok and colour improvement as the fish grows...
Just don't tell him, it'll make him sad LMAO...no it doesnt affect the size or growth, he will even go through breeding process, just less of a chance of being successful. That is a really nice fish.