given they are likely from the same batch, i would say they are most likely Florida gars. the first one is definitely a Florida gar, but the second one, given the pic presented, could very well be a shortnose. would be odd to see one at this time in the year, but anything is possible these days. if you can get a few more pics of the second one, including a dorsal shot if possible, we could get you a more solid ID.--
--solomon