How long has my brother got?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

A. gigas

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Apr 19, 2010
2,886
2
68
here's the story: i went upstairs to take a look at my brother's 3 gallon bowfront tank, and i see a frickin' oscar in there! i asked him why he bought an oscar, and he said this: "they stay the size of the tank they're in, and IF it gets too big, i can just use YOUR 20 gallon.":screwy: he bought a fish, then thinks he can just use my tank (it doesn't even have a filter or anything, i'm getting a watersnake for it soon) and then he tells me "and if it somehow outgrows that, we can just sell it, and if we can't find a buyer, we can just let it go." i mean, WTF?!?

OK, here's the actual question: how long can it live in his 3 gal?
it's about 1.5-2 inches long, and is happily eating hikari cichlid gold. (and lots of it. he doesn't even spit out the pellets) the tank is one of the tiny ones that you buy in the box with the filter and everything. he is alone in the tank except for a 3-4 inch common pleco:screwy: that he bought with similar thoughts(my brother is always both ambitious and unrealistic, not a good combo.)

i'm guessing it has already outgrown the tank, or will do so in about a month or less.
 
Yeah its already outgrown in mate, and probably already up to its gills in sh*t. Time for an upgrade or move it on. Shame, as they are awesome fish but your bro needs a lesson on impulse buying at the LFS...
 
I KNOW...

the tank is actually quite clean, the gravel is white, and there is virtually no crap on it. the filter is actually quite powerful...
 
Eeek! Steal the fish and bring it back to the pet store. then ask them why they would sell an Oscar to a person with a 3 gal tank. That's just wrong.
 
here's the thing. he told my mom that 20 gal was big enough, AND that i had said he could use mine! then, (knowing the filthy liar that he is) he probably told the store he had a 100 gal all set up for it.:shakehead
 
Dude, as much as it sucks just let it happen. Get him to clean the tank and show him the ropes. I have bought my bro so many things for fish to try to get him into the hobby its not even funny. Try to embrace it, and really teach a younger one the proper way of keeping. I bought my brother a 90 gallon sw tank with filtration skimmer stand etc, and even a 14 inch bamboo shark and a 6 inch bamboo shark and a purple tang. He still doesn't clean tank, or feed them for that matter. I wish my bro would take an interest like yours


thats not including the 3g, or the 55g. This is what he ultimately wanted.....
 
Take both fish back to the store and trade them in on a Betta - it's the only real responsible move if you can't at the very least get a 75 gal tank - niether fish can live very long in 20gal of water let only 3.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com