I would definitely do $50 for that fish. GT's are common but there are so many in the hobby that are gaunt with thin, faded orange trim on the fins. That fish has good genes regardless of the tear in his fin.
nc_nutcase;3370756; said:If I were in your shoes... I would be more concerend with finding it a good home, than a good price tag...
Personally, if I knew someone in my local fish club who wanted to rehome that GT... and I had space... and I was interested... I would offer them what they paid for it and would promise it proper care...