Hypothetically would this work?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Acura_RSX;2424226; said:
whats your point? I already have the 50 bought .. money is gone. in the sellers hand. i own it as soon as I pick it up. and whats wrong with them being in the ten gallon? all together at the moment the fish equal like 10 inch's. maybeee 11 .. so yah. and next wed they will be in the 50

Awesome! Did they get over their ick issue?
 
Acura_RSX;2424226; said:
whats your point? I already have the 50 bought .. money is gone. in the sellers hand. i own it as soon as I pick it up. and whats wrong with them being in the ten gallon? all together at the moment the fish equal like 10 inch's. maybeee 11 .. so yah. and next wed they will be in the 50

So you still don't own it yet. Either way, no to the IDs. You won't find a sensible individual that would condone a pair of IDs, not in your 10g, not in a 38g, not in the 50g that you'll allegedly be getting. Not in a 120g, maybe in a 240g with your stocklist. Either way the answer is no. You might want to take a knife and carve that into your forehead backwards so you see it every time you look into a mirror. Maybe that will help you understand what EVERYONE here is advising you to do. If you want to ask for advice and refuse to listen to it, why even join the forums? You surely don't contribute.
 
Yeah this guy is being stubborn plus hes doing noob mistakes. What happens when they grow out the 50 gal? You might as well drop this stock list and go for some fish in the 4-6 inch range, that way you can have a few in that tank and not have to worry about them outgrowing the tank.


ALL your fish get too big and theyre all incompatible.
 
Acura_RSX;2406681; said:
With the right size tank and lots of care .. Hypothetically all bought as juvies I suppose would it be possible to keep ...

1x iridescent shark
2x bala sharks
1x redtail black shark
1x oscar
1x angel fish

possible to keep these together or where would my concerns be?
So many possible problems

Bala v redtail
Oscar v everything
angel fish v everything

Or you never know it may work out and everyone gets alone great but I doubt it
 
oscarcrazy;2424354; said:
Awesome! Did they get over their ick issue?

almost. they are starting to eat again. and they have lost most of the ick on their bodies just waiting for it to be completely gone before I put them in the 50 gallon.
 
So your gonna put all these monsters in a 50gallon when i 6 months they will all out grown it and end up killing each other? I hope you power feed the ID shark before it gets killed by the oscar. Then the ID will bust your tank, problem solved I guess.
 
I read that Pangasius loose their teeth at large size and must eat plants so if it was big enough no problems
but you'd need like 450 gallons
 
Selective reading I suppose. For the fishes' sake, I hope he smashes the 50g while moving it and rehomes the fish b/c even he can't be dumb enough to keep them in a 10g... right?
 
Pyramid_Party;2424547; said:
Yeah this guy is being stubborn plus hes doing noob mistakes. What happens when they grow out the 50 gal? You might as well drop this stock list and go for some fish in the 4-6 inch range, that way you can have a few in that tank and not have to worry about them outgrowing the tank.


ALL your fish get too big and theyre all incompatible.

alright man i'm open to suggestions. shoot some at me. some 4-6 inch fish that are complete predators. Picking on each other lil doesn't bother me. happens in the ocean. happens between people, honestly who hasn't been in a few fights before? it's life ... I'm not too worried about that. And by the way the smaller of my two iridescents didnt' make ti through the night. :(:(:(. the ick finally got to him. I have a new thread to open asking a question about adding stuff soon anyways back on topic .. Anyone with suggestions of predatory .. maybe mean fish that olnly get 5-9 inch's? and i'm nto a fan of just like cichlids .. they are alright to have I guess but just seem like normal pretty fish that you could see in a doctor's office tank. So i'm open to suggestions. I thought about piranna's but i'm not sure. still debating it.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com