I don't think trashing guys on this forum is doing any good.
If I was him, read that post, chances are I would never return to this site. Constructive criticism with an emphasis on teaching someone what it takes to keep certain fish is the way to go.
When I first started out, I had an 18 gallon tank. In it, were 3 oscars, 2 red devils, 2 tinfoil barbs, 2 Red Bellied Pacus and a common pleco. I learned.
How many Red Tails are sold every year? Out of those, how many will actually make it to adulthood? I would say less than 1/10th of a percent.
This site is WONDERFUL for sharing info, pics, getting excited, and teaching others what it takes to keep fish and keep them responsibily. As well, we are all hobbyists here. Many are very new, but it is our job to try and encourage other hobbyists instead of flaming them on the forums.
This is a haven for guys who enjoy keeping huge fish. Lets keep it that safe haven where we all can learn and where we can all pass knowledge on. Not to mention, there aren't too many other sites around where we can boast about our fish and put pics up
