ID Hap

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
All juvie and female Hap are almost identical, I have heard talks by experts that say they can't tell them apart, and never mix species because of that reason.
If its a young male, you will need to wait until it colors up.



Thanks Duane for your input as always .
 
If there are any Hap experts here, I edited your photo a bit to help.
fullsizeoutput_4ad.jpeg
You might want to send the shot to Steve Lundblad over at Wet Spot, he is a Hap expert, he goes collecting in Africa, and is nice guy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Impossible to say with any certainty, even by an expert. It could even be of mixed blood, unfortunately this is quite common when fish with no provenance are purchased. Good luck.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Again, can never be too sure...but looks like a juvie red empress. Like others have said, if it's male...when it colors up, will be a much easier time to tell.

It's not a great picture because mine never wants to stop moving, bur the fish in the middle is a red empress. He has colored. Again, horrible pic...but bright blue face....orangish body. Has the same black striping as yours.

20170623_074404.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Again, can never be too sure...but looks like a juvie red empress. Like others have said, if it's male...when it colors up, will be a much easier time to tell.

It's not a great picture because mine never wants to stop moving, bur the fish in the middle is a red empress. He has colored. Again, horrible pic...but bright blue face....orangish body. Has the same black striping as yours.

View attachment 1263209


Thanks so much and the pic is good.☺
 
Also, IF it's a red empress and IF it's male. They are beautiful fish, but a pain in the a**. We have had 2. Could of sworn both were female.

The first male had a really small blue dot by each of his gills. LFS told me, it's male. He is waiting to size up to change color. Sure enough, he got the same size as the dominant fish in the tank and colored up. He was about 4 inches though!

The little guy in the picture is maybe 2.5 inches. Thought was a female. We bought him a little while after the original red empress had been in the tank. The thing wouldn't grow. This time no color hint whatsoever. My dominant fish kills my bigger red empress. This little punk colors up within the same day that his other competition was killed off. Eating like a pig the next morning.

So, they do color, but it can be very painfully slow and they do actually time it on purpose. Depending what else you have in the tank, if it is a red empress, it's potentially waiting for something.

If it's female, it'll stay the same color it is now.

Mine is going to have to get very aggressive as he gets older if he's going to survive my tank. Fingers crossed bc they are beautifully colored!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com