ID, is this down eye?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
C.A.S.A.;3982878; said:
Really!?!?!?! My father in law had a 2 foot Silver that was housed in a tank w/ gravel (no reflection) and got droop eye.

i was kidding....alot of us beleve that fatty foods fall into the same catogory as looking down/refletion...they see no reflection it is just how our eyes see the angled glass through another pane of glass...

also alot to most suport the "head trama" theroy as a major part if not the cause of de...it is kinda singeled out in the thread you found...
 
C.A.S.A.;3982972; said:
Didn't own the fish per-say but i did help feed it, take care of it for 4 years.

So how were you able to determine that what you fed it gave it DE?
 
Of the two big silvers I raised, one had drop-eye and one didn't. Both fed the same food, although the drop-eyeless one was fed much more sparingly. Also, it was the one that never jumped...
 
C.A.S.A.;3983107; said:
gold fish was his main diet.

I have two silvers that have never been fed goldfish. Only high quality pellets/sticks and shrimp and they both have DE. So how could the goldfish cause DE?
 
C.A.S.A.;3983107; said:
gold fish was his main diet.

you should read all of the thread you found...this is one of those topics where you think you know cause your brothers uncle had an aro and you helped feed it sometimes...cause of this you feel knowlagable in arowana care and ect... alot of people do this, but untill you have sucsessfully raised a few in your tanks and you see them 24/7 then you shouldn't try and come up with a cause...witch that cause you have come up with has been proven wrong every time someone like yourself brings it up as the cause...did you ever see the aro jump? theres another cause...don't take this personal, but i knew he was setting you up to fall on your face like that...it has happened before...like i said read that thread you found...
 
C.A.S.A.;3983204; said:
I'm just telling you what happen in my isolated situation from my experience.

yes, but did you see it jump or did it ever jump...did someone metion it jumping...you really can't cancel out a reason/cause if you don't check all the possibilities...both brian and i have seen de happen before our eyes, after a few hours of an impact...along with several others...
 
C.A.S.A.;3983204; said:
I'm just telling you what happen in my isolated situation from my experience.

There is no way you have any proof to claim that the foods you fed are the cause of DE then, right?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com