ID please

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Dalfrey86

Piranha
MFK Member
Apr 8, 2020
370
304
77
39
I took in a group of fish so they wouldn’t be left for dead, I know a mistake on my part but I couldn’t let the fish suffer.

All I know at this point is that they are either South American or Texan cichlids.

can some one help with the ID?

61F179CC-2EB2-46AF-B9A7-A324D5C5DF6D.jpeg

DD3F48EF-426B-4966-9B38-D4248D8B41EF.jpeg

196F2853-46EA-4E1A-A4BD-745B244569EC.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Magnus_Bane
The bottom pic looks like a washed out rainbow cichlid
 
I’m thinking I got more of a grab bag of “I dunno” than what I was told. Only bonus is that I got a 2 year old pleco and a smaller pleco.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lp85253
I’m thinking I got more of a grab bag of “I dunno” than what I was told. Only bonus is that I got a 2 year old pleco and a smaller pleco.
I think that top pic may be a brasiliensis..
 
if we are playing guess the fish, I'll throw my ideas out there.....

pic one looks like a three hybrid Texas types and what could be two small Jewel cichlids.
pic two is a Red Empress Haplochromis, a stressed out Rainbow cichlid and as a complete shot in the dark based on one head on picture ...a Mayan cichlid.
pic three is the stressed out Rainbow and the Hap's butt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Magnus_Bane
Oh yeah, no denying they are stressed to the hilt. I plan on giving them a week or longer to really settle in and flourish.
 
To me the 1st pi looks like someones attempt at a "red Texas". It's pretty obvious its ancestry is Herichthys, and maybe mixed with some other Central to bring out the red.
Here's an Herichthys to get my drift.

below a member of the Geo braziliensus clade to compare.

and I agree the African is a Protomelas taeniolatus (red empress)
As for the 3rd, the fish is showing a stress pattern, soa few other pics after it gets more comfortable would help, but here are some Herotilapia multispinossa to compare



In the pic above the ones on left and right are "rainbows" the mid is Cichlasoma dimerus.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com