Ideal aquarium fish for me.

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Eupterus

Gambusia
MFK Member
Dec 11, 2006
934
2
16
Bennington, VT
Let me start that I probably won't be getting said fish for a while, if at all.
When I started to think about how I like some aspects about my catfish and some things about my bettas, and how they both have negatives I don't like so much.
I got to thinking, what is my ideal aquarium fish?. Does such a fish exist?.
Possibly a catfish and betta like fish rolled up in one?.
If such a fish does not exist, I wonder which fish comes in closest.

Here are a list of traits my ideal aquarium fish would have:
- Would require a 250 gal tank max size to thrive as an adult.
- Size would be open besides being able to thrive in above tank size or smaller.
- Would be vigorous and able to thrive in normal aquarium conditions.
- Would thrive in hard alkaline water.
- Would thrive without special needs and special care.
- Would have a lifespan of at least 10 yrs.
- Would be interactive and responsive towards people.
- Will at least swim towards the lid for food.
- Would be adorned with some colors.
- Omnivore or herbivore fish preferred.
- Would be captive bred.
-Would be available as a rescue pick up if not captive bred.


What the ideal fish would not be:
- Extremely predatory with a big gaping mouth, the kind of that is found to have swallowed tank-mates on a regular basis.
- Endangered in the wild and wild caught for the aquarium trade.
- A weakling that dies at the drop of a hat without specialized care.
- Dies during the first vacation the fish keeper takes.
- Hiding excessively.
- Dull brown colored.
- Completely ignoring the fish- keeper.
- Require a small pond as an adult in order to thrive.
- If on the larger side, viciously biting or otherwise harming fish keeper making tank cleaning more difficult.
- Be a cichlid ( long story, some may know why).
 
Funny you should mention goldfish as they are on my wishlist.
I've gotten mixed responses as to how responsive they are, other then that, the only real drawback is they need high volume water changes.
 
i have a good one for you. red tailed giant gourami. all that you want rolled into one. all the traits and all. i think it's very well qualified for your wants.
 
Most of your criteria for what you would like to have describes neo-tropical cichlids, but cichlids are out so the first things that come to mind for me are Kissing Gouramis, or a single giant goramy(osphronemus gourami), I have no personal experience with this fish, but I'm sure somebody on here does. They are fascinating and personable. Also the clown loaches was a nice suggestion.

Naldo

 
I agree that goldfish and giant gouramis are good choices for you. I would also suggest flagtail prochilodus; I'm not sure on their lifespan but they fit the other characters.
 
peewee;3473483; said:
i have a good one for you. red tailed giant gourami. all that you want rolled into one. all the traits and all. i think it's very well qualified for your wants.

Excellent recommodation!
 
Thanks for the suggestions peeps...I think I have new dream fish:).
A fish that comes in gold and likes to eat watermelon?...score.
If things go right(obviously not sure where things are going hence no concrete plans) , one or two special fish is enough. At any rate, I'm going to use my dream fish in artwork for now.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com