I'm Pissed!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
fugupuff;523892; said:
I guess I wasn't convincing enough... :( Here is what the paper replied...


Dear Wes:
Before I even went to the tackle shop, I contacted DNR, which sent out the
fisheries biologist in charge of IDing and certifying Maryland catches. He
has more than 25 years of experience.
I asked him specifically if the fish was a Pacu.
He told me that he has seen many Pacu--aquarium discards in local waters
and in their natural surroundings--and was sure this was a pirahna.
I double-checked his ID with the National Aquarium in Washington, which
concurred.
As far as the northern snakehead story, I broke that story. The fish in
Crofton DID NOT come from a restaurant. The two fish came from an aquarium
owned by an Asian man, who bought the fish so he would have a ready supply
of fish to make soup. When they got too big and his mother refused to
prepare anymore soup, he tossed them in the pond across the street from his
condo.
I have the police reports that include interviews with the men, who would
have been charged, but the law wasn't clear enough to make charges stick.
Further, in the creek behind the Dundalk tackle shop, there are two Oscars
swimming near the dock. So, sadly someone is in the habit of discarding
aquarium fish when it becomes inconvenient.
Sincerely,
Candy Thomson


what a DUMB...!!!!!!
 
Here is what I've replied to her email:

Dear Candy,

Thanks for taking the time to write back. I myself have 20 years of fish keeping experience, have kept thousands of piranhas in the past, different species, and was an active member in the piranha keeping community. I currently own an aquarium fish store, and also import and export fish on regular basis. I can bet you anything, that the picture depicted is of a pacu, and not piranha, the suspected red belly piranha has not even been recorded at that size, ever.

Did the guys at the National Aquarium see the actual fish? I've forward this article to other authorities on this subject to further support my claim. Hope you would consider looking into this one more time.

Best Regards,

Wes
 
OMG
 
The latest...let us all be civil now. She has been real courteous so far as to wanting to find out the truth. And she is working with Frank from the p-fury board on making the corrections, that is who she is referring to the foremost authority on piranha. As far as the other scientists at the DNR...he's the big arse in my opinion, aren't they usually?

Reminder, we have to be courteous and respectful for people to respect what we do as hobbyists. The people who've expressed otherwise, please edit your posts and present yourself in a more professional manner so we do not become targets of criticisms!

Wes:
I have emailed a man considered to be the foremost authority on pirahna, a
Smithsonian scientist who works in the Amazon basin.
Believe me, I want to get this right. I had no intention of misleading
anyone, which is why I went to two biologists instead of just one.
The first biologist went to the tackle shop and opened the fish's mouth.
Before he became a DNR biologist, he worked at the National Aquarium.
He believed then and now that he ID'd a pirahna. Ditto the National
Aquarium biologist.
I will make this right if it takes me the rest of the week.
Thanks for being civil. A lot of folks haven't been.
Sincerely,
Candy Thomson
 
fugupuff;524065; said:
The latest...let us all be civil now. She has been real courteous so far as to wanting to find out the truth. And she is working with Frank from the p-fury board on making the corrections, that is who she is referring to the foremost authority on piranha. As far as the other scientists at the DNR...he's the big arse in my opinion, aren't they usually?

Reminder, we have to be courteous and respectful for people to respect what we do as hobbyists. The people who've expressed otherwise, please edit your posts and present yourself in a more professional manner so we do not become targets of criticisms!

Wes:
I have emailed a man considered to be the foremost authority on pirahna, a
Smithsonian scientist who works in the Amazon basin.
Believe me, I want to get this right. I had no intention of misleading
anyone, which is why I went to two biologists instead of just one.
The first biologist went to the tackle shop and opened the fish's mouth.
Before he became a DNR biologist, he worked at the National Aquarium.
He believed then and now that he ID'd a pirahna. Ditto the National
Aquarium biologist.
I will make this right if it takes me the rest of the week.
Thanks for being civil. A lot of folks haven't been.
Sincerely,
Candy Thomson


Your just trying to get in bed with her..... with a name like candy you are curious if she is sweet....:drool:
 
fugupuff;524065; said:
The latest...let us all be civil now. She has been real courteous so far as to wanting to find out the truth. And she is working with Frank from the p-fury board on making the corrections, that is who she is referring to the foremost authority on piranha. As far as the other scientists at the DNR...he's the big arse in my opinion, aren't they usually?

Reminder, we have to be courteous and respectful for people to respect what we do as hobbyists. The people who've expressed otherwise, please edit your posts and present yourself in a more professional manner so we do not become targets of criticisms!

Wes:
I have emailed a man considered to be the foremost authority on pirahna, a
Smithsonian scientist who works in the Amazon basin.
Believe me, I want to get this right. I had no intention of misleading
anyone, which is why I went to two biologists instead of just one.
The first biologist went to the tackle shop and opened the fish's mouth.
Before he became a DNR biologist, he worked at the National Aquarium.
He believed then and now that he ID'd a pirahna. Ditto the National
Aquarium biologist.
I will make this right if it takes me the rest of the week.
Thanks for being civil. A lot of folks haven't been.
Sincerely,
Candy Thomson


Thank god she's actually trying to make a positive ID. The moron I got in Iowa just cared about a news story. Good luck Wes!
 
dont get a cavity....

keep it up fugu!!!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com