OP, I was in the same situation. The 10" leporinus was doing a great job at messing with them tigers all the time so they didn't turn on each other too much. Then I added a third tiger, same size at around 9"-10". The new one quickly became The alpha, which was very interesting. Then I added 5x redhooks, 3"-5", which I later regretted. The Alpha got bullied by the other two dats, got hurt and then died.
What I tried before adding the third dat was adding a big 13"-14" pink giant gouramis, which really kept the two dats in check. The tank was peaceful till the GG got to around 16"-17", when she turned to the dats hunting them down to the point I had to put up a divider. Then later I gave the GG away. So you may want to try adding a bigger fish, may be a pike or aro, if you still want to keep the two dats.
Good luck, and keep us posted as I'm interested to hear what direction you take.
What I tried before adding the third dat was adding a big 13"-14" pink giant gouramis, which really kept the two dats in check. The tank was peaceful till the GG got to around 16"-17", when she turned to the dats hunting them down to the point I had to put up a divider. Then later I gave the GG away. So you may want to try adding a bigger fish, may be a pike or aro, if you still want to keep the two dats.
Good luck, and keep us posted as I'm interested to hear what direction you take.