is a ok combination

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

champlin42

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Oct 6, 2008
12
0
0
wisconsin
:feedback:


i was wondering if everyone thinks this combo would work if not give me some suggestions.

125 gal tank.

2-ebjds
2- jds
1-salvini
1-rainbow cichlids
1-pleco
2- yoyo loach
1or2- herichthyes labridens
2- convicts
 
I would remove the salvini and the regular Jack Dempsey. Electric blue jacks are not that agressive, also no convicts. Unless you want a more agrresive tank. The rainbows are mildly aggressive along with the ebjd's Convicts salvini and regular jacks are very aggressive.
 
i think it will be ok. i have JDs, cons, and a salvini together and they all get along fine
 
Allan01230;2331820; said:
I would remove the salvini and the regular Jack Dempsey. Electric blue jacks are not that agressive, also no convicts. Unless you want a more agrresive tank. The rainbows are mildly aggressive along with the ebjd's Convicts salvini and regular jacks are very aggressive.
EBJD's are actually known to be more aggressive then normal morph JD>

yes i think that would be ok
 
balton777;2331998; said:
They are? :confused:

I've never heard that before.
yes, well as im sure you know very well that each fish is individual and has its own personality!

but i post on the EBJD forum and most people say how there EB's kick the crap out of the JD's

just some fool who once said, EB=wuss comp to JD
 
yeh its just a roomer, well thats what i was told on the EBJD forum and im sure if anyone knows, they will on there.
 
Well I don't ever recommend ever keeping the same species of aggressive fish in the same tank like two JD's but an exception is a bonded pair. Even still you will be limited if a pair forms on what fish you can keep in there with them. Rainbow WILL get beat on by the Salvini without a doubt in my mind. Salvini are not like cons. Yes cons are aggressive but no where near Salvini. All my salvini ( 4 males) Beat down anything. When one was 4-5 inch he beat down a 10" motaguense and killed him so... But they are more territorial but once a fish crosses the territory line Salvini just go nuts on them. I say

1x Salvini
1x JD
1x Labridens
the pleco
a couple cons no problem because they could definately hold their own.
and MAYBE an EBJD.

There are other fish out there too. I am sure you probably want to just go to the Store and buy whats common because you have easy access but there are 1,000's of cichlids to choose from so I would reccommend looking around a bit before committing. A great place to get some good rarer cichlids is Jeff Rapps at Tangledupincichlids.com hey you might find something else that catches your eye.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com