is he growing properly??

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
anyone ever been bitten by their gar doing a water change? a little convict chicilid
bit me ounce and scared the crap out of me,(thought it was a crayfish) now im nervous putting my hands in my tank with my needle fish..ouuch!
 
you're refering to false gar, pike characin i think. neat, but not cool imo. true gar all the way!(although mine were STOLEN!!D:)
 
Mampam;2088099; said:
i was told gar grow an inch a month
mine grew 1 1/2in from july 12 to august 12

is that slow??? its a florida gar, how is that slow??

whata they do??, go on hyper speed the first most then suddenly slow down??
they only get 12in their first year, that doesnt make any sense

i can understand an alligator gar, but a florida gar that my only grow 18-24in?? that fast the first month.... please......


and yes i put the quotes around expert, cuz he told me my florida gar should be 7in in 2months, HA!! i dont believe that

oh! shucks! i wonder why people would always flame you.

its senseless to answer your questions cause you always have your own answer that is contradictory to what people would give you.

i mean OH GOD you think something is wrong even if its back-up with years of documented research just because you believe so? JUST STUPID!:screwy:
 
Mampam;2088099; said:
i can understand an alligator gar, but a florida gar that my only grow 18-24in?? that fast the first month.... please......

and yes i put the quotes around expert, cuz he told me my florida gar should be 7in in 2months, HA!! i dont believe that
wow your blatant arrogance is just too much!

it doesn't matter what you choose to believe, the facts aren't gonna change.

and if you have all the answers already, then why even post a question!? Puh-lease!
 
Mampam;2085001; said:
ive had my florida gar since July 12 and hes grown from 1in to 2 1/2in, is that good???

if ur wondering why im asking
i was told that he should be 7in in 2 months, and since im not an "expert" i must be wrong about everything right???

so my gar should be about 4in now rite??? cuz an "expert" told me the above

i didnt catch the quotes on expert. im not an expert but i am mostly right about what i know and dicuss about these fishes.
 
im wrong ok?? whatever, i just didnt make sense to me, thats all, i dont care anyway, at least he IS growing (i can worry about a larger tank much later)

it must be something with the water, cuz my yellow bullhead grew only 2in in 8months, (1in to 3in) idk how big he is now, cuz hes in the pond, so its probably the same reason for the gar

it could just be the fish, cuz iv been told by many other ppl (with many yrs of experience) that some individual fish grow rapidly, and some grow slow ass hell

example: someone from another forums yellow bullhead when i was told, was 3yrs old, and only 7in
 
all gars have the same growth when they are that small.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com