Is Rihanna a music ICON???

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I always call him Justin Timberland. Every time I see his name I think of my work boots. Honestly I couldn't name one song any of these people ever sang. IMO every one of them is to icon an like the mayor of my town is to George Washington.
 
The only person on this thread mentioned who deserves to be called an Icon is Timberlake. Rhianna, if she keeps it up for another decade then she will be. Bruno Mars... again if he keeps it up long enough, he will be. Icons are made over a long long time IMO.

Sent from my DROID4 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

Usher? He's had a better career then all 3 of those combined

Same with B

Timberlakes has like 3 solo albums?
 
^ i couldnt either lol, im mainly into punk, dubstep and progressive metal like coheed and cambria. Only reason i said Timberlake is that hes been around for so long and has drummed up quite the following

Real music Icons, Jim Morrison, Roger Waters, Eddie Van Halen, Claudio Sanchez, hell macklemore is more of an Icon then people like rhianna and mars purely because he is striaght originality.

Sent from my DROID4 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Justin has sold about 67 million records over his 20 year career though.....

He's outsold Whitney and Madonna in a day and age when nobody buys CDs anymore.

And downloads aren't recognized by the RIAA as album sales. They are considered "licenses" and don't qualify, but if you count those as well, he's sold well more than half what the Beatles have sold altogether

Not too bad for a 32 year old boy band graduate. Maybe not Icon worthy today, but way moreso than Rihanna


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
Jim Morrison now your talking my music Mr. Mojo risin! Member of the 27 club.
 
^ all hail the LIZARD KING!! theres another whole group of icons, EVERYONE in the 27 club, Janis Joplin, Hendrix, the guy from Nirvana who's name escapes right now etc

To Ballin, Usher.... is Usher. He's just another R&B guy who doesn't do anything unique. New Kids on the Block are icons in R&B

Edit KURT COBAIN (guy from nirvana)
Sent from my DROID4 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
^ Even Amy Winehouse, I really liked her music. Another 27 club member.
 
^ all hail the LIZARD KING!! theres another whole group of icons, EVERYONE in the 27 club, Janis Joplin, Hendrix, the guy from Nirvana who's name escapes right now etc

To Ballin, Usher.... is Usher. He's just another R&B guy who doesn't do anything unique. New Kids on the Block are icons in R&B

Edit KURT COBAIN (guy from nirvana)
Sent from my DROID4 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App

Wtf did nktb do that was unique? Steal from black groups? Suddenly it was unique cuz they were white?

PS, not only does usher have the long career, no flop albums, insane concert sales.....but show me a single pop or r&b cat that has his dance moves? Don't worry, I'll wait
 
Hah,made me want to puke back then when I saw girls and some guys walking around with NKOTB buttons on their clothing.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com