Planted tanks and cichlids don't really go together. My fish tear up my fake plants. I would try to snatch up another jaguar! IMO Jaguars, Oscars, FH, JD can live together but sometimes due to their aggressiveness they might hurt each other or worse kill each other. I had all of them together at one point plus more aggressive cichlids and all knew their pecking order. I never got a Jaguar or Oscar because they have big mouths and can swallow fish if they wanted. I keep 2-3" fish with 12" Midas/ Flowerhorn so if that was an Oscar and he got hungry or mad he would eat it.