Jar, lei, & black aro...

[David R]

The answer is only good when it pertain to the question! And you did use your psychic power to assume that he's going to keep 3 "giant" arowana in a 125-gal tank!

? <- that this is called a question mark, and denotes a sentence as a question (well at least it did when I went to school).

Just wondering i have in separate tanks an black(6"), lei(6"), and jar(6.5") and was wondering if they could be in a single 125g? would the jar scrap with the black and lei? or vice versa?

I've followed your lead and highlighted the question marks in red. There are three question marks signifying three questions, although the third is really just an extension of the second question;

Just wondering i have in separate tanks an black(6"), lei(6"), and jar(6.5") and was wondering if they could be in a single 125g?

and

would the jar scrap with the black and lei? or vice versa?

I didn't attempt to answer the second question as I felt it was irrelevant if he was planning on keeping the three fish in a 125g. I answered the first question based on the information presented in the post, which was that he had three arowana and a 125g tank and was planning on keeping all three of them together, there was no mention of a larger tank or the 125g being a temporary measure. In hindsight I could have elaborated and said that they might be able to live together in that tank for a while but you would need to upgrade your tank in the near future, but then I probably would still have been flamed for not being a mind reader who knew there was a 360g tank waiting.

 

[Bderick67]

Because of lack of info givin on the OP's part and other unknown factors the answer to all three questions would be... maybe.

I am to assume the 125g has water in it, is properly cycled and filtered. However, if not, then no. All the aros will die but at least they will not fight


BTW, why did you post this in the "Arowana media lounge" if you are not posting any pictures or video?

 

[David R]

Assumption is the mother of all f-ups. Should I have assumed that he had a bigger tank, or assumed that he was a noob who thought fish will only grow as big as the tank they are in?
Maybe I'll just ignore questions posted with insufficient information, probably safer, at least then I won't be accused of not "read [between the lines] before type"....

 

[Unattended Fish]

well yes i am a noob that has been in the hobby for 9 years that has not that much experience with aros. geez wtf just asking a question...
and yes the tank is cycling it has the single black aro in it. As for little info... that is what a reply is or i can't reply back? For posting in the media lounge sorry wrong place can mod move please.

 

[jlnguyen74]

? <- that this is called a question mark, and denotes a sentence as a question (well at least it did when I went to school).

I've followed your lead and highlighted the question marks in red. There are three question marks signifying three questions, although the third is really just an extension of the second question

How does it get from "post" to "sentence" and "mark?"

Did we read the same post?

 

[David R]

well yes i am a noob that has been in the hobby for 9 years that has not that much experience with aros. geez wtf just asking a question...

As I said, I've got no idea who you are, what experience you have, and just answered your question based on the [little] information in your post. Don't take it personally, how was I supposed to know the 125g was only a temporary measure when you made no mention of a bigger tank?

How does it get from "post" to "sentence" and "mark?"

I'm not even sure what you're asking now, and I don't really care. Good on ya Mr Internet Toughguy, I've learned my lesson, I'll make sure I "read before type".....

 

[Unattended Fish]

well thats when you could have replied and said will hold them for a little while but, will be needing a larger tank soon.

 

[Bderick67]

well yes i am a noob that has been in the hobby for 9 years that has not that much experience with aros. geez wtf just asking a question...
and yes the tank is cycling it has the single black aro in it. As for little info... that is what a reply is or i can't reply back? For posting in the media lounge sorry wrong place can mod move please.

The tank is cycled or cycling? Not a good idea to keep a black aro in a tank that is not completely cycled.

 

[Unattended Fish]

sorry wrong phrase of words it is cycling and has been for about 2 months now. Black is doing great just looks alittle lonely...lol i like that little guy<--

 

[Bderick67]

From looking at your other thread, it does not appear that you black in doing great.