Leaking tank please help

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Man, this thread's almost as heartbreaking as Matteus Matteus moving thread when he just couldn't get a break from bad news.

I've been watching all along. You've had some great advice to guide you from other members but I guess it just wasn't to be. It's fantastic you took the job on in the first place and even though it failed in the end you have learnt something from the experience.

Well done young man.
Thank you. Not giving up on it yet though. As soon as it’s done draining I’m going to dry it out and remove the silicone on the inside and reseal it tomorrow. Even though it was leaking I continued to fill it to the top with water and all of the sides stayed up without any leaks for an hour and a half maybe 2 hours while it was draining. This time I won’t be taking the tank all apart either I’m just going to remove the inside silicone with a razor and reseal.
 
  • Like
Reactions: esoxlucius
Bummer, but like I said, this is good experience no matter how you look at it. There are a lot of keepers here who are all talk, it's nice to see a new keeper who's not afraid to put in some effort. A few things to improve on if you try again:

-i don't think this tank cured properly. Immediate cause of the failure imo. Next time build in a sheltered area that won't get too hot and is out of the sun.
-Let your tank cure for at least a week, 2-3 weeks even better. Small jobs will be ok after 72 hours but the silicone deep in the seams takes a longer time to cure.
-make sure you leave no gaps in the silicone when you're laying in a bead.
-you will need to use some sort of mechanical braces to clamp the vertical seams of your build. Even if your bottom seal had held up I don't think the sides would've made it over half full. The duct tape was insufficient imo. While glass appears quite smooth, you need pressure on the seams to force silicone into the microscopic nooks and crannies of the glass and get the best hold. Just dont overclamp like I mentioned before either.

Best of luck if you try again someday. I know theres been criticism as far as the "value" of rebuilding a 55g, but make no mistake it's well worth it to make a first build attempt on a tank this size...you don't want to make these mistakes on a big tank that could really do some damage.
I appreciate all the help and comments from everybody. I’m not done with this project yet. Albert Einstein didn’t give up on the lightbulb after his first failed attempt. I’m not giving up on the tank after the first failed attempt. I now know what worked well and what didn’t do so good. If we gave up on everything after the first try then we would get no where in life
 
Last edited:
I appreciate all the help and comments from everybody. I’m not done with this project yet. Albert Einstein didn’t give up on the lightbulb after his first failed attempt. I’m not giving up on the tank after the first failed attempt. I now know what worked well and what didn’t do so good. If we gave up on everything after the first try then we would get no where in life
One problem: Albert Einstein did not invent the lightbulb.
Wishing you the best of luck with the tank! I’d love to build one one day!
 
Ok I’m throwing the project away. I hate to do it but my mamaw called me and said if I stop working on this one and throw it away then she’ll buy me a brand new 55g from the store. She was there ready to buy it while on the phone with me and I’ll be getting it today. I’ll be letting it cycle with brand new water and letting it cycle for a month before I add the FH to it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deeda
Ok I’m throwing the project away. I hate to do it but my mamaw called me and said if I stop working on this one and throw it away then she’ll buy me a brand new 55g from the store. She was there ready to buy it while on the phone with me and I’ll be getting it today. I’ll be letting it cycle with brand new water and letting it cycle for a month before I add the FH to it.

Push for the 75...much better dimensions.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com