Couldn't agree more, mine was barely 5" and an absolute terror.
This Christmas I thought I would finally get a Ghost Knife, however given the LFS was out and not wanting to come home empty handed, I ended up deciding to take a chance on a good priced 6" Leporinus fasciatus. I've researched them before, been meaning to experiment for myself, since I've always seen mixed reviews; from killers to community tank worthy.
So I put him in my old 75 barb tank; 8" spanners (as well as a swarm of tigers), 5" loaches, 6" red tail shark, 4" CAE's, and 12" plecos. Well, at least I thought they were semi-aggressive.
The first day I over observed him, since I knew their might be problems. However he was a perfect 'angel', he actually schooled with every fish in the tank, eat well, no problems. As days progressed, I noticed a nick here and there, although seemed just territorial. Finally today I was taking some pictures, and holy cow, he had actually taken numerous nicks out of every single fish in the tank, shredded an entire tiger barbs tail fin, numerous marks on the side of red tail, and had turned a 12" large pleco into permanent hiding.
What a pain, he was yanked today and placed in one of my planted tanks (which from what I hear I need to watch out for them as well). This one was far from capable for a community tank. Buyer beware.
Ed