There are some nasty strains of Velvet out there... and its like pepper covering the fish... and resembles Ick alot.. but appears more.. hazy.. My bets on that. Ive had a strain wipe out my comm tank in a few days despite anything I did ( the lfs i bought the fish from also lots almost 50% of their stock, and its a huge well respect fish store)... my fish just keeled over like flies.. its nasty.. and horrible. But it can happen to anyone. IMO let it run its course with anything living left for a month... if after a month your survivors are healthy and otherwise everything is normal add a few fish. Recycleing the tank, breaking it down ect... won't guarantee anything.. time, patience, and abit of dilligence will imo.