Midas Protogyny

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

nomadofthehills

Candiru
MFK Member
Nov 1, 2005
573
2
48
While studying for my ichthyology final, I found an interesting excerpt in the reproduction section of my textbook, The Diversity of Fishes by Helfman et al.

"Social control also explains protogynous sex change in the Midas Cichlid, Cichlasoma citrinellm, one of the few freshwater changers. Large fish tend to be male, smaller fish are female. Growth rate depends on behavioral interactions of juveniles, with dominant fish growing faster. The size advantage model again explains the course of this change, since female Midas cichlids mate preferably with larger males. This preference is adaptive, because the male has primary responsibility for defending the breeding site and larger males are better defenders (Francis and Barlow 1993)."


Any personal experiences or opinions?
 
nice info man i read this somewhere to ...it was long time ago...ive never see it though
..i have in clownfish
 
Hey guys
I've been very interested in this stuff - but this is new for me, with Midas Cichlids.
I must however question the article, because as we all know, Midas Cichlids often fool us with which sex they are. I think it's too likely that the sexes were not fully determined, and "oops" a male appeared....
What do you think??? I'd love to see this happen with KNOWN sexed fish... has anyone witnessed anything of the sort?
 
I have read the paper on sex differentiation in Midas cichlids. It is not really convincing that midas actually changes sex during its development. I just don't see how sex ratio (especially from a small number of samples) and larger size have anything to do with sex change. The author's chi-square test results do not reveal anything except that in general that male is larger than female in Midas cichlids.
 
Certain species of frogs and other amphibians have been known to change sex so i'm sure fish could do it too. I remember seeing a documentry on dinosours that when faced with......oh no wait that was Jurasic Park, never mind.
:ROFL:
 
i think that this needs a better test then the one they did
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com