Agreed, anyone who has owned a 14inch cichlid will know an 18inch wide tank it too small as far as swimming space. I put my old 14" butti in my 100g for a few day temporarily and it looked ridiculous. A lone 14 inch fish should be the same size tank as for keeping 3-4 fish at that size, it shouldn't be about whether you can manage the nitrates, it should be about what looks right. My old butti used every inch of my dd 300g.
Finally the wieght of a fish increase exponentially with each extra inch, a 14 inch oscar weighs close to twice that of an 11 inch oscar, so if your oscar ever gets close to 14inch your in trouble with a 75g. I would bet alot of members havent seem a properly measured 14 inch tall bodied cichlid in a 75.
+1 FOR 150-180G FOR A LONE 14" OSCAR.