My dumb idea (planted+marine+mullet)

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

seds

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Aug 23, 2008
308
0
0
Canada
Is there anyone who has a marine tank that isn't a reef tank, but instead focuses on marine algae and seagrasses? It could be based on sandy shores and tidal pools. I went to mexico a while back and I loved the marine plants I saw. I also saw some really neato fish that no one knew what they were called, and marine fish charts for the area didn't list them. They were silver torpedo shaped fishes with tube like mouths, black edged tail and pectoral fins held out like wings.

Turns out the neato fish I watched in fast moving shoals by the shore was Mugil cephalus, the striped mullet.

:nilly:
"Mullet, unlike the rest, are just and mild,
No fish they harm, by them no seas are spoil'd;
Not on their own nor different kinds they prey,
But equal laws of common right obey.
Undreaded they with guiltless pleasure feed,
On fattening slime, or bite sea-grown weed."


a1933_lg.jpg

http://www.aquarticles.com/articles/saltwater/clark_grey mullet.html
Here is a neato article on mullet in the marine aquarium. Read this to understand better my ideas.(it's where I found the poem)

Turns out they are very hardy, live life in brackish or marine conditions and even head into freshwater from time to time. They often get trapped in tidal pools when feeding once low tide comes, so that would make them extraordinarily hardy for marine fish. Tidal pools get really warm during the day and very cool at night. The only thing I found about anywhere else is using them as baitfish or something. I searched here and found a thread about keeping one but it was discouraged. I suppose this was because the tank was too small for the adult and people didn't research their diet or whatnot. Many marine fish are wild caught to begin with, why not catch your own?




ANYWAY here was my plan.
http://i229.photobucket.com/albums/ee86/88seds88/GetAttachment-1aspx.jpg
http://i229.photobucket.com/albums/ee86/88seds88/GetAttachmentaspx-1.jpg
Marine tank, 220 gallons or larger. Big jagged rocks in the corners to hide filter output. These rocks would probably be the kind of rocks on natural shores, riddled with holes and stuff. Sand covering the rest, with random leafy algae covering the rocks in the corner.THEN add the mullet, 5 or 6 of them! These fish feed by sifting sand or gulping water, filtering with their gill rakers to get organic matter. This would be so close to their natural habitat, I wouldn't be too surprised if I could get the suckers to breed. If that happened I could start the mullet trade in marine or brackish aquariums. I would use polyurethane to hide the box filter in the corner... the box would drain into a sump and I would have a refugium for some sort of creature, maybe plankton, crustaceans or some little cardinalfish.



I am aware that grey mullet are not the same species but almost all mullet have very similar characteristics... Mullet are in the genus Mugil and they are very similar.

Also these things are 100% peaceful filter feeders. Apparently it is really easy to get them onto dry or even flake food! Are they the magical just add water marine fish? Who knows. I guess since I live 1000 miles from the nearest ocean I will never get them... until I move to a temperate coastal town. They aren't in LFS for a good reason...The only thing keeping these cute fishes from being suitable for the average aquarist is their size... most get 12-20 inches in length... Hence the large size of the aquarium! Ironically there is groupers at most any marine store that get bigger than that. I suppose the mullet's silvery color is another factor... Some people aren't fans of silvery color. Tankmates include anything other than marlin, barracuda, tuna and sharks. My personal choices would be a few pajama cardinalfish, or black tailed humbugs, or perhaps a trigger or filefish. Then again, I could easily set up a false marine tank with the similar looking bala shark... using the exact same setup ideas. (only freshwater of course)
:screwy:

Thoughts? Am I stupid? Am I crazy? I am thinking maybe 220 gallons (72'' long) might even be a bit small for these active fish. I saw them in the wild and they do swim restlessly and hastily wherever they are going. Perhaps this fish is to remain a symbol of the wild, just as the mullet hairstyle is a symbol of the past... Another problem is they may uproot the plants by foraging. That is why I would focus on planting the rocks in the rear and corners of the tank.

Yes I did post this on another website slightly edited.



Plants:
Codium bursa
Caulerpa prolifera
Caulerpa Sertularoides
I dunno the other kinds I want. Couldn't find much info on marine algae except how to get rid of it?!

Fish:
2-4 Mullets
2-3 sergeant major damselfish or 1 trigger





Anyways please keep comments intelligent. I know I know you eat mullets or feed them to your fish. If that is all you can say then don't bother...:irked: But seriously.. Is there a way to get them shipped to me when I am prepared to make this setup happen? I want to get them over the border legally as possible. How do people ship fish all over without getting in trouble?

If you have a marine planted tank, tell me about it! Does it need the same fertilizers? Does it matter weither you use marine lights or freshwater pink tubes? Do they need CO2?
 
there's probably 20 species of valonia and probably 200 of caulerpa.. you're going to need to be a *LITTLE* more specific, lol

good idea if you're into that, though i think 5-6 mullet in a 220 is a bit much... maybe 2-3

the cardinals or damsels i think are just going to get eaten (especially the cards)
 
K thanks. I 'll try to find a more specific plant.

And find bigger tankmates. I like the black durgon triggerfish but that thing is maybe a bit too big. Sergeant Major Damsel might be a good one.
 
nice idea! good luck with it!
 
Thanks, I will be needing luck. I think I will get this up within 2 to 5 years but I am only 16 and aren't allowed to set up a new tank ATM.

:(

But I can plan and save in the meantime.
 
big damsels would be a great option
 
Keep in mind that they seem to be grazing fish. If that is the case, they may not be as suited to small aquaria keep. Even a 200-400 gallon tank will not suffice. You may need something along the lines of 4000-20000 gallons to keep a small few.
Not to say it isn't possible, but this may be beyond most means of keep for aquarist.
You are 16 years old. Even with 5 years of thought or beginning to attempt this, I feel this would be well beyond your means or even others that have kept a mature tank over 30 years.
Certain fish were meant to stay in the ocean.
Hope this doesn't discourage you in any way, but there are plenty of other fish that would be more adapt to aquarium life.
 
a 4K tank i was excessive

they are zooplanktonic feeders and woul get by on forzen preparations

even grazing fish dont need collosal tanks in captivity
large oceanic tangs, triggers, and rabbits only need a tank in the couple hundred range

dussumier tangs would be fine in like a 700 gallon tank and that's a 2.5 foot long lawnmower

i do agree that a 200 is a tad small but something like a 4-500 would be about all you'd need


these aren't exactly pelagic fish that require vast expanses of pristine water, they're found close to shor and even in river deltas, they are pretty used to poor conditions (assuming there aren't any captive bred ones, which i doubt)

i think if he ups the tank size a little they'd do quite well
 
maby you should think about somthing like a saltwater pool/pond with a window
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com