my new pink-tail

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Does anyone have groups? I would like to get 6 of each for my 450 but I don't want them to kill each other

You know, it's funny. I see a lot of (mis)information stating that chalceus need to be kept in groups, I guess whoever writes it doesn't understand the risk of them killing each other like tiger15 tiger15 mentioned!
In fact, I once encountered someone on Loaches Online who believed it was a schooling fish, but they no longer disputed that it wasn't when I mentioned tiger's account of a group being reduced. Schooling fish just don't do that.

My $0.02 would be to stick to 12 of one species instead of 6 of each. That means you have twice as many to spread the aggression out amongst, and therefore lessen the chances of any one fish getting killed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: celebrist
You know, it's funny. I see a lot of (mis)information stating that chalceus need to be kept in groups, I guess whoever writes it doesn't understand the risk of them killing each other like tiger15 tiger15 mentioned!
In fact, I once encountered someone on Loaches Online who believed it was a schooling fish, but they no longer disputed that it wasn't when I mentioned tiger's account of a group being reduced. Schooling fish just don't do that.

My $0.02 would be to stick to 12 of one species instead of 6 of each. That means you have twice as many to spread the aggression out amongst, and therefore lessen the chances of any one fish getting killed.

I don't know for certain what the group rule is for chalceus but I know just 2 or 3 of the same species is no bueno (another reason I'm trying to figure out my particular species) while it seems like 2 of different species can be fine together like tiger15 has shown.

It also could be that smaller groups could more or less be possible depending on species. I see a lot more pics and videos of erythrurus in pairs or small groups than macrolepidotus or epakros. This could be also due to erythrurus' apparent popularity over the other species I assume because of their flashy colors.
 
  • Like
Reactions: celebrist
Maybe I will do one of each after I set up a 55 quarantine tank, kinda spendy to experiment with
 
The only time they school is when they are fry. At 2 inch size I found in dealer tanks, they were already sparring with one another, a few were stressed out at the corners, and many have broken nose from banging the wall or locking jaw. I have rare pics of a 1000+ gal SA tank in the now closed National Aquarium in DC where several PTC were cruising solo at the surface. Their bright color, loner demeanor, and immense size caught my eye before I know they are.


IMG_4233.JPG

IMG_4237.JPG
 
Mine would sit motionless for most of the day. Then at dusk he would actually swim about some.

Jex yours looks like true macrolepidotus, mature individual with the darkened line covering approximately 1.5 scales above the lateral line as described in the article I referenced earlier. Did it ever show red spots at all like the others we've posted? You got this one from wet spot too?
 
The only time they school is when they are fry. At 2 inch size I found in dealer tanks, they were already sparring with one another, a few were stressed out at the corners, and many have broken nose from banging the wall or locking jaw. I have rare pics of a 1000+ gal SA tank in the now closed National Aquarium in DC where several PTC were cruising solo at the surface. Their bright color, loner demeanor, and immense size caught my eye before I know they are.


View attachment 1495164

View attachment 1495165

It closed? They don't have the arapaima tank anymore? That's terrible and news to me. It was my favorite exhibit at dc zoo.

Edit: my bad, I thought you meant the Amazonia section of the zoo. I was never even aware dc had a national aquarium.
 
Jex yours looks like true macrolepidotus, mature individual with the darkened line covering approximately 1.5 scales above the lateral line as described in the article I referenced earlier. Did it ever show red spots at all like the others we've posted? You got this one from wet spot too?
I still have all the receipts from the fish I have bought from The Wet Spot. So I looked it up and they sold it as a Macrolepidotus.
20210321_194702.jpg
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com