My own brother, oscars in a 40!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Newt

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Jul 18, 2005
1,105
1
68
Michigan's UP
Yep, my older brother (41) has two oscars and a common pleco in a 40 gallon! Nope, not even the 48" 40 gallon, but the 36" 40 gallon at that!

He was telling my mom at lunch that the LPS didn't tell him they got so big so fast, right now they are pushing 6"+ each. They made the tank really dirty (DUH!) so the LPS sold him a common pleco to "clean up the tank"! Then he had green water and cloudy water (gee, maybe because he put the fish in the same day he set up the tank?) so the LPS sold him some bottles of "stuff" to put in the tank to clear it up.:nilly:

Wait, get this: my niece wanted goldfish so he bought some of the "cheap ones" (ie: feeders) and put them in the tank. He was mortified that the oscars ATE the goldfish:screwy:

My mom asked why he didn't call me when he set up the tank. Guess my family didn't know I was that into fish:irked: Hello! For the past 20 YEARS I've had tanks. I told my mom that a 40 gallon is actually a good size tank to start with, you can do a lot with it, just NOT put oscars and a common pleco in it!

Thing is my brother has the money to set up a killer tank of any size if he wanted; he has the room, his house is huge! I have some cool ideas for that tank running through my head right now, but he HAS to bring the oscars and pleco back!
 
Thats embarassing! My brother would never think of doing something to a tank without asking me first.

Chad
 
Well, the evil me thinks that I should just sit back and wait until he gets so fustrated he gives up, then I can have the tank.:evil_lol:

But, in reality I'm going to go over, test his tap water, see what kind of fish will do good in it and have him bring everything that he currently has in his tank back to the FPS he bought them from.

:tropicalf
 
newtothis;558468; said:
Well, the evil me thinks that I should just sit back and wait until he gets so fustrated he gives up, then I can have the tank.:evil_lol:

But, in reality I'm going to go over, test his tap water, see what kind of fish will do good in it and have him bring everything that he currently has in his tank back to the FPS he bought them from.

:tropicalf

Nooooooooooooooooo... getting a 220 soon tell him to give them to me.:D
 
Its not ok to keep a single oscar in a 40..... Oscars need ATLEAST 55 gallons and that by most people's standards is even small.

Chad
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com