Need a little help deciding

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Festae or Breidohri pair

  • Festae

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Breidohri

    Votes: 3 37.5%
  • Other, please specify in thread

    Votes: 5 62.5%

  • Total voters
    8
Thanks for the comments and suggestions. This is exactly why I posted, to get feedback. Everyone has a different set of opinions and I appreciate all of them. Keep them coming as I am in no rush to go out and buy something that will not work long term.
 
2 Loiselle is a great suggestion, 2 Friedrichshtali, a harem of Jack Dempseys, or Firemouths, 2 Green Terrors (MAYBE a harem), a harem of Salvinis, 2 Brasiliensis, either species of Herichthys, (2), MIGHT be able to do a pair of Red Devils or smaller Amphilophus, but I wouldn't try the larger ones and if you do Amphs, introduce a small sub-adult male to a full-grown female after she's dominated the tank.

Personally I think Green Terrors are the answer or Brasiliensis - both CAN grow to 11-12", but more commonly 8-10" for males, and females generally stay around 5-7", but any of the fish I mentioned will work, plus every smaller species you can think of.

Im gonna play Devil's Advocate, cuz you are limited by length, BUT you STILL got 190 gallons to play with

Some fish are gonna LOVE the 36" width
 
  • Like
Reactions: cichlidfish
Before I can really answer or give a suggestion, I have to ask. What are your looking for? Color? Personality? Something unique? Single fish/pair or a community setting?
 
Last edited:
Since all you specified originally were festae and breidhori, and wanted spawning pairs, here's my take.
I have kept both, and many others.
I believe the festae at spawning maturity might be a bit crowded in that size tank, unless you had a perfectly copacetic pair.
My breidhori spawned in a similar size tank, at only about 5", and did fairly well until they grew too large, but in the mean time spawned another 2 or 3 times in that tank, raising lots of fry.
I almost always try to start with at least half dozen youngsters, and grow them up together, allowing them to choose there own partners. That doesn't assure you of a copacetic pair, and a few young hierarchal (less expensive) deaths should be expected, but I believe it ups the odds a bit. It does take more time and patience, but to me its better than buying expensive adults, and watching them kill each other.
Where I lived, I could usually pick up youngsters for $3-$5 each of both those species, and maybe cheaper at my local aquarium club auctions, where it was not unheard of to pick up a bag of 10 juvies of everything from some Vieja to dovii, for a buck or $2.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frank Castle
I say mix it up with a few pairs of Tanganyikans with lots of small cavage. Brichardis,leuleupis,julidichromis etc. They keep relatively small territories and seem to respect borders when established.
 
Although limited in length the tank has a nice wide foot print.
I think it would make a great tank for some small to medium sized substrate sifters.
A,robertsoni,A rostratus,Thorichthys or some of the smaller south American geophagus or gymnogeophagus.
Any of the above would work well as a small group in a species only set up with a sandy substrate.
Personally I think briedori and festae get too big to keep for the long haul.If you must have one of these I think briedori is the best of the two.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frank Castle
MonsterFishKeepers.com