Yep, Duane pretty much nailed it. Big +1.
I believe there are experienced aquarists (like Andy) that have over those years become intuitive about what works, and what may not. They can put together fish in tanks that other aquarists cannot, especially those noobs with only a couple years in.
He did mention that the Amp in the tank killed his prize one, and would only tolerate that single dovii, and notice that there are only two fish in a tank, (although not gallon large) but with a large footprint, and that they have been together for years. Fish are capable of selective relationships just like other animals, this is why cichlids go thru mating rituals, yet just because you put a female and male together, doesn't necessarily mean they will breed or stay together after a spawn. Bondingwith cichlids can be complicated.
OP if you are willing to spend the money, and sacrifice a number of fish getting there, go right ahead, and truthfully document the progress over time, I'd be (and am sure others would be) interested in how many trials it takes to get to a compatible tank mate. May be lucky with 1, or may take 10 deaths or more.


