New additions

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Buphy

Dovii
MFK Member
Jun 10, 2015
1,265
292
107
34
Texas
So I'm considering moving around fish between my tank but as they are both cichlid tanks there are many potential problems. At the moment I'm considering moving my 2.5-3" GT into my 55 with my 3-4" JD, EBJD and paratilopia bleekeri. (Yes I know full grown they will need a bigger tank and have one planned for the next year or so.)

The reason for this potential move has several reasons. 1) the theory that aggressive fish do better together when introduced younger. 2) I feel like I'm in a not so sweet spot of too many fish for everyone to have their own territory but too few to have the territory not matter. To this idea I've seen tank with far more fish per gallon than I would have personally done but are fine because the aggression is spread out (or that's how it was explained at the time.)

So my current plan if I do move the GT is to bag all the fish, redecorate the tank, and then rerelease the fish starting with the GT. I'm worried because of size this might not be enough so I was looking into dither. Walking through my LFS I saw rose line Sharks (and other names they are known by). Though they are more expensive how do y'all think they would act as "dither". They seem fast, school and are very nice looking.

In conclusion while all advice is welcome I'd prefer to avoid the "you need to move the paratilopia NOW!" I've heard it, it's fine now, and I'm constantly keeping an eye on it with a back up plan if and when he does need to be move. ^.^ Thanks in advance for your advice!
 
24 hour bump... I'd really like to hear y'all thoughts on this. To resume up...

Would roseline Sharks make good dither? Any other recommendations apart from giant danios? (Don't really like how they look)

Will my plan work or will everything just out grow the already smaller GT? (I've heard they're slow growers)
 
Jd, ebjd and gt are all slow growers. I'd say the Jd will grow the fastest though.
It can work for a little while they're all still pretty small. But you won't really know until you try.
As for dithers, I'd try tiger barbs. If you can find any large enough to not get picked on. My ruby barbs are with a convict and they do well with him.
 
Tiger barbs are nice, that'd work well for me in the 55 I think.
 
At that size I don't see a problem. I have no experience with Bleekeri, so I can't give an opinion about that.
Dithers may not be needed. Add hideouts I think it would work.
 
Ok, so there's a vote for no dither. As far as hiding goes, if I redecorate it will be with my parents old coral they had in their tank before I was born. Sure there's enough to make good hiding.
 
On a side note, if JD are slow growers what does that make jeweled cichlids?! Had a pair I got at the same time as everything else at the same size and the JD and EBJD "outgrew" them in a few months and I had to rehome the jewels.
 
I didn't know I can vote for no dither. I always vote no dithers in cichlid communities.
I mentioned barbs because I figured you were set on putting something else in there.
 
Not if I don't need it. Why vote no always?
 
Dithers in aggressive cichlid communities are basically punching bag fish. Not a fan.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com