New arrivals Paretroplus Menarambo from TUIC

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I removed a pair showing signs of spawning, to what I thought would be a less stressful tank, because they had eaten all previous spawns.
Major miscalculation on my part.
The move destroyed their pair bond, and when I tried to return them to the main tank all hell broke loose between all 6.

I had a similar situation with my pair. Each time they spawned (and after I removed the eggs) the male would relentlessly pursue the female. She managed to keep enough out of harms way to avoid serious injury until they were ready to spawn again (about 2 weeks apart). This repeated three times. After the fourth spawn she was taking more of a beating than usual, so I moved her to another tank for recovery. After a week or so, when I felt she was back to normal, I moved her back. A day later, I found her dead. I'm not sure what happened to her. She may have been killed by the male, but actually, there was little damage showing. I think in order to maintain this species properly, a large tank is required , quite a bit larger than the 90G that I had the pair in. Also, keeping the numbers up (6+), providing plenty of structure for "safe havens" , and keeping the group together and stable (don't separate and re-introduce) is the way to go. I have, just as you Duane, inadvertently made matters worse by removing and re-introducing fish. Having a couple of other damba species (kieneri, dambabe) in there might be advisable too. I'll try this with the young 'uns coming up. Also, I believe that raising them up together from a young age can improve things in quelling aggressive tendencies.
 
I had a similar situation with my pair. Each time they spawned (and after I removed the eggs) the male would relentlessly pursue the female. She managed to keep enough out of harms way to avoid serious injury until they were ready to spawn again (about 2 weeks apart). This repeated three times. After the fourth spawn she was taking more of a beating than usual, so I moved her to another tank for recovery. After a week or so, when I felt she was back to normal, I moved her back. A day later, I found her dead. I'm not sure what happened to her. She may have been killed by the male, but actually, there was little damage showing. I think in order to maintain this species properly, a large tank is required , quite a bit larger than the 90G that I had the pair in. Also, keeping the numbers up (6+), providing plenty of structure for "safe havens" , and keeping the group together and stable (don't separate and re-introduce) is the way to go. I have, just as you Duane, inadvertently made matters worse by removing and re-introducing fish. Having a couple of other damba species (kieneri, dambabe) in there might be advisable too. I'll try this with the young 'uns coming up. Also, I believe that raising them up together from a young age can improve things in quelling aggressive tendencies.

I most definitely agree with you folks. I started with a group of 15 in a 220 gallon tank. The fish would breed regularly and I would remove the eggs for incubation. The 3 or 4 couples that formed would fight a bit more during this period but because if the ample space, no injuries were ever significant. Later I moved to another house and replaced the irregular 220 for a rectangular 240. The surface area was smaller so the fish didn't breed as often and there seemed to be more bickering. I removed a few of the non-dominant fish and introduced young menarambo to provide breeding stock for years to come. Ever since the remaining adults started breeding again after 11-12 years of life. My group is very stable and I think it is from mixing young and old and having kieneri in the same large tank. I raise a few hundred of each species of Paretroplus every year and the work involved raising fry is really tough but well worth it.
Regards.
 
This is all great info guys thanks. I'm toying with the idea of picking up a group to grow out. Post up pics as they grow OP.
 
Thanks everyone! Very helpful input. I couldn't ask for better resources :)

I've been trying to get clear pics of my new Damba. As you know, they're very active once they've settled in to their new environment. This young group is between 1 to 1.25 inches, already showing vertical bars which look (to me) like smudged eyeliner. Looks like their colors change often like my other Malagasy cichlids. Even at this size, they're sifting and 'head shaking' with exuberance. No problems eating either, crushed BBS flakes and .5 mm NLS pellets. Their mouths are still quite small but that doesn't stop them from constantly looking for food.

Best pic so far

View attachment 963131


Video a few hours after arrival

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5WMR7Fz6yzE

Feeding video from this morning

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ceIK0DPAKQI


Sent from my Nexus 10 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Anyone keep these singularly?
 
Anyone keep these singularly?

If I'm remembering correctly, they've been kept alone with other species when the Menarambo was the last remaining fish in a group. I'm hoping those who have done so will chime in. Not that its my intention, but I'm also interested in knowing how the lone Menarambo fares with other species as an adult.

Sent from my Nexus 10 using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com