NEW SILVER DOLLAR PLANTED TANK – Consolidating 2 established Planted SD tanks

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Update. New dollars in quarantine, destined to the new planted tank (eventually.... at least a month away). It has been 4 days.
Four small (< 2 inches) Metynnis fasciatus. First time I have this species, and they will join the other 3 spp. I am certain these are tank raised.
Already learning to eat algae (nori) and not eating too much a plant in the Q-tank. Plant is one of what I have been calling Hygrophila sp. (may be wrong), but which adult dollars of 3 Metynnis spp in other tanks do not eat, or at least too much.
I am already aware of what I consider minor fin rot (white on tips of tail fins) and am currently treating for that. Hopefully they will soon be clean!
Metynnis fasciatus Qtene 2021 Sep 29 comp.jpg
 
Small update...
Added several new plants to the new tank. Even with sort of a plan of where to plant what, it became rushed because of lack of time and becoming overwhelmed. Thus I placed several in what I see now as not great and temporary places, to be changed in time as needed including to other tanks. At least the plants are in, beginning to root, and hopefully will take and begin to propagate. (of course later there will come the SDs so we will see...)
In addition to the same 4-5 plant species I was using successfully in the other SD tanks, the following new plant species are listed below; in parenthesis my rationale for adding these particular plants :

Cryptocoryne undulata (SDs already didnt eat C. wendtii or C. ulsteriana)
Hygrophila araguais (SD's already didnt eat Hygrophila sp)
Hygrophila pinnatifida (already didnt eat Hygrophila sp)
Microsorum pteropus "Windelov" (already didnt eat regular java fern)
Anubias barteri "nana" (supposed to have bad taste and not eaten much by other plant eating fish)
Ludwigia broad leaf (a gamble! chosen because it looks nice)
Nesaea pedicellata 'Golden' (a gamble! chosen because it looks nice)

I have not yet added floating frogbit/duckweed. I will certainly introduce it in a floating corral soon, before fish. Although it is possible that the SDs will come and eat everything as salad, my suspicion and hope is that it wont be the case for all plants. The ones I fear for the most are Ludwigia and Nesaea, but I wanted to try them.
Unfortunately at this time all plants are from Asia and Africa (although H. araguais is rampant in Brazil, possibly introduced). However, I know that amazon swords and other SAmericans will be destroyed. Hopefully I can find some species I can introduce later on.

The tank is suffering of a bit of 'new tank syndrome", with some blue green cyano growing on surfaces a bit; this is not unexpected; I am trying to control/eradicate it, and hopefully won't delay my plans too much.
More to come, with (hopefully) clearer pictures (better focus), and at least some fish.
Cheers!

IMG_0473 Crop.jpg
 
Small update.
While new dollars are in quarantine, old dollars in their old planted tanks, and plants continue to take hold in the new tank (fishless), I decided to try one of the new plant species in one of the old SD planted tanks. Kind of a look-see what happens.
Ludwigia repens 'broad leaf', a single bunch at left has been in the tank for 2 days and nobody has nibbled it! (yet?). This plant is native to North America, and when happy it develops a very attractive red/purple color. In front of it, a carpet of sorts of Cryptocoryne wendti 'bronze', a plant the dollars don't seem to eat, and which has been growing there for 2 years. The stripped headstander, A. anostomus will come in with the dollars.

This little test may or not foretell what may happen to that particular plant species in the new tank, once the dollars come in, from 3 separate tanks, and will find 12-13 established plant species.
I am still fighting 'new tank syndrome' in the new tank (cyano), but believe things will clear up soon. Cheers!

IMG_0487 Crop.jpg
 
Too slow, I know. Three small updates -
1- The little test with the Ludwigia repens 'broad leaf' bunch in one of the old SD planted tank, ended in near extermination of said little plant by the lonely two males M. lippincotianus and one male M. altidorsalis. There is a tiny bit of the plant left (after nearly 3 weeks), but it is mostly gone from both nibbling on, and just by pulling on it by the fish. So that was not successfully for that plant, by those 3 fish of Metynnis, in that very tank (I am trying to keep the various variables separate).
At the same time, all other existing (4 species) types of plants in their tank were not nibbled on.

2- I re-scaped, by taking out part of the wood (I had 2 pieces attached as one), and taking out some of the rocks. I think it is now more pleasant, simpler looking, and much easier to clean and work on. The main reason was the realization that the tank is not that big, and with the various adult fish coming, it was now clear I needed the space, both for the fish, and for the plants which are hoped to grow profusely as in my other tanks. Empty tanks always look huge; and then you add water...
Most plants are doing well, some better than others, but none is dying, and not quite flourishing yet, but certainly rooting and putting new growth and good color.

IMG_0506 acrylic1 crop.jpg

3- After one month+ in Qtene, the baby tiger SDs M. fasciatus entered the new planted tank. They have been there for 60 hours now. I had introduced 4 Otos, 1 small pleco and 2 Brochis sp. a few days earlier., and the tank itself has been running for 3 months with ghost shrimp.
The 4 little fasciatus are about 2 inches, and assertive and very active, boisterous about, swimming back and forth, much unlike the calmer, posed stance of the adults. They look great! You can barely make them out in the tank picture above, at the bottom center. Too small. For now the little ones think they are the bosses, not suspecting that soon the big dollars are coming in.
It is early to say anything meaningful but thus far they have not been eating the plants noticeably, and are eating the various foods they are used to (frozen mixed inverts, flake, pellets, nori, garbanzos). During quarentene, they knew only one plant species (Hygrophila sp.), which they did not eat (or much), and which is one that thrives in the other two dollar tanks.

The first 5 adults to come will be the 3 M. maculatus (1 female, 2 males) and 2 female lippincotianus, probably by this weekend. They will be followed sometime afterwards (week?) by 3 additional fish, 1 male M. altidorsalis and 2 male lippincotianus, to complete 12 SDs, 2 Brochis, 1 bushynose pleco, and a few otos.

Metynnis fsciatus 2021 Nov 3 comp.jpg

I have to learn to take better pictures in the new acrylic tank. It is quite different than doing so with the glass aquaria. Perhaps a combination of inherent hazyness , unfavorable reflections and who knows what is making my pictures hazy and not quite in focus. I need to learn to improve upon that.

Cheers!
 
I jumped the gun.
"The first 5 adults to come will be the 3 M. maculatus (1 female, 2 males) and 2 female lippincotianus, probably by this weekend."

So much for that. My wife and I did it last night. All 5 fish transferred uneventfully.
By today they seem to be settling down nicely, starting to think of this new place as a home. The little tiger dollars are afraid, and are not the centerpieces any more. Little seen by the corners. Aquarium seems fine. I gave a little nori (not much eaten), and will feed lightly tonight.
No comments about plants yet. There were no comments about the little dollars alone with the plants either.

IMG_0515 Crop2.jpg


IMG_0527 Crop.jpg

More to come...
 
That is something people say about ‘all silver dollars’. What do you think?
I think the real issue is that there are dollars and there are dollars, and there are plants and there are plants. Somewhere in there there is room for some compatibility.

Aren't black bar silver dollars carnivorous? Those might be some of the ones suitable for planted tanks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
Looks good. Looking forward to seeing those plants fill in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
Aren't black bar silver dollars carnivorous? Those might be some of the ones suitable for planted tanks.
I’m pretty sure all of the dollars lean herbivorous, but you could be right.
 
Weird. I had heard somewhere (forgot the source! Darn!) that the black bars prefer meat, and since it lined up with the mention here of plant friendly silver dollars, I saw no reason to doubt it.

Others' experience would certainly help, ofc.

Edit: just saw your edit. Let's see if anyone has any experience with whether they prefer plants or meat.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Deadeye
MonsterFishKeepers.com