Online Fish stores

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I've personally ordered from Pedro before and gotten top notch fish. I know several other members have as well, plus some of my personal friends have too.

I've also ordered from Rapps several times, and can name at least three different occassions, one of them my own, where one fish was sold as one thing, and turned out actually to be another. I also know of several people who have been 'burned' by Rapps. Does that mean I'll never buy from Rapps again? No. People make mistakes, things happen. He still has quality fish, and at great prices.

The same goes for Pedro.

If you wait long enough, you will find bad reviews for just about EVERY online retailer there is. It just comes with doing business online.

However, like camshaft so expertly pointed out, you can't just base your opinion on buying from him by one person. In this case camshaft was wronged by him, so his opinion is biased towards negative. You should look at both sides of the story, then make up your own decision, instead of just hearing one side and making up your mind.
 
I am extremely biased. I'm blinded by hatred....I admit that

But there are two sides to every story. It just so happens that my side is the right one....;)
I think, for me, it's that out of all the places and people I've ever purchased fish from (and there are quite a few), he is the only one to ever disappoint me.
 
Horiyoshi III;3517943; said:
Once you are on TUIC you'll forget what Oscars even are...
Just look around that gold mine.

Yea I looked around TUIC, but I could never forget what O's are! They are by far my fav fish, I just love them! I want to get an aro but I dont have a properly sized tank for one, so it will have to wait.:( Also thanks everyone but the whole mail order fish deal kinda spooks me so Im gonna go ahead and just hit up the LFS and pick out some nice baby O's today, My ammonia and nitrites finnaly bottomed out but my nitrates are off the charts so I gotta do some mondo wc's to get them down before I go grab any fish.
 
Color to some degree will change.. seriousely.. Oscars.. go with personality. Few fish I've kept with as much as these guys. I sat for about 20 minutes infront of my O's tank at the petstore just watching him/her before buying. I had no intention of getting an O again ever. Color caught my eye, but after walking around, and comeing back to the tank time and again. And finally just stood there watching. the LFS owner laughed at me 'n asked when i was ready to have it bagged to let him know. 3" to now pushing close to 10" still no color on him, always say the day he/she gets and color to him is the day I toss him on the BBQ.. But 'm absolutely lieing. One of my favorite fish. Go for Color and Personality and you'll love no matter what one you pick out in the end.
 
I've ordered from a Rapps 4 times and he did mess up once. It seems the difference with Rapps is that he made it right for me quickly and without hesitation, whereas Cam says the other guy couldn't have cared less. Jeff is a stand out guy IMO and I would recommend him to anyone looking for great quality and service. Anyway though, good luck with your lfs order and if they can't get what you want, try TUIC.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com