Oscars are meant to die.

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

knifegill

Peacock Bass
MFK Member
Sep 19, 2005
8,782
113
120
43
Oscar Tummy
Since my Oscar won't eat broccoli, am I to assume that he's going to die? How can this hobby tell me to feed my adult fish every other day, but also tell me HITH is caused my malnutrition? If I feed him more often, the nitrates get too high. If I don't, he apparently gets HITH. It's just one hole over his right eye, but it's a nail in his coffin and I know it. And I did everything this time. The water is electrically grounded. The only charcoal is the same old charcoal that has always been in there in the penguin cartridge. He has never seen ammonia in my tank, and nitrates only once climbed over twenty. I change 90% of his water every week now. He eats crickets and mealworms which have been gutloaded, and otherwise eats Massivore and other high quality pellet foods. PH stays at 7.2. Temp always 77ºF. There is nothing else to do but watch him die. Slowly. I thought I had it beaten, too. It's been almost a year I've had him...just like the first Oscar. And this one's wild-caught, too. I did EVERYTHING right. Everything...

Oscars are all set to self-destruct. Don't try. They just die.
 
i don't understand at all. i don't think broccoli grows in the rivers, but hey i could be wrong.
 
Nutrition, nutrition. How am I supposed to feed my fish less and more at the same time? He doesn't eat vegetables.
 
malnutrition doesnt just mean not eating enough, it means not eating the right things, even though you seem to be feeding it well. put him in a bigger tank if the water fowls feeding him every other day

my advise is buy fish vitamen supplements, use them to enrich its food it does eat.
 
I guess I'll take the whipping from the budget-guard and buy some liquid vitamins. What is a good brand?
 
i here people like vita chem and selcon
 
i never feed my O's anything but pellets .. maybe toss in some frozen whatever and market shrimp if there is any laying around .. but 99% of the time its the same ol pellets .. and i only do 20-30% w/c every other week .. mine do great .. they are hardy fish IMO
 
Probably should keep fish that are not prone to HITH. I don't think there is a proven reason for HITH so how do you know ya did the right things?
 
Some oscars are more genetically prone to HITH than others. My two oscars have had the same living conditions all their lives and yet one has had HITH for a long time now while the other oscar has never had a sign of any hole at all. Great diet, great water perameters, everything perfect. Still one of them got the damn condition anyway.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com