Paratilapia polleni and plants

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Giwrgos1991

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Nov 9, 2019
48
29
36
34
Hi to all! I would like to know if a paratilapia polleni is going to be gentle with my anubias and java fern in my tank.

Tank is 220 gallons with a very large driftwood and lots of anubias/java fern on it.

It's really nice aquascaped so I would like to be sure before adding this cichlid (as far as possible).
 
Here was my Paratilapia tank.

I used very tough aquatic plants like Java Fern, and Anubius, and semi-aquatic plants like Papayrus

They like put their eggs in plant root masses, and don't necessarily uproot or eat other plants, but I believe any delicate plants may be seen as an occasional salad bar snack.
 
These are some nice photos but this doesn't clearly answers my question :p

If there is a chance that polleni will start shredding my anubias (just like oscars), I will not consider putting one in my tank.
 
These are some nice photos but this doesn't clearly answers my question :p

If there is a chance that polleni will start shredding my anubias (just like oscars), I will not consider putting one in my tank.
There are no absolutes in the aquarium hobby.
It is science mixed with a sort of natural art.
In most cases Paratilapia leave plants alone. But.....
If your individual cichlid decides your landscape does not fit its territorial, and/or personal space protective requirements, it will tear it all up, and because as an adult, it reaches a size of @ 12", it has innate the ability to do so.
If you want a 100% guarantee, get a school of neons, don't get cichlids.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Milingu
Did you not read what he posted?

Firstly, your words are far from polite Rocksor. Do you think that I haven''t read what someone wrote in a thread that I posted?

As I said I want to be SURE that this fish will leave my plants alone because if you have decorated a 50 kg driftwood with so many plants, which also required two people just to be moved into the tank, you would have known that this to be shredded in one night by one fish would be a consequence that you wouldn't be able to afford.

Duanes thank you for your time to answer, for posting such beautiful photos and with your second reply made clear that this is not a 100% guarantee.

However, as for the school of tetras. That was unecessary my friend, I have in the tank an Asian aro, 4 geo surinamensis and a black ghost knife fish that are 100 sure that will not ruin the landscape. So not only a school of tetras is a guarantee.
 
In my answer I was not trying to be facetious, or snide by using small tetras.
There are cichlids that eat plants, (some large tetras do too)and there are those that tear up plants to provide an easily visible defensive position.
But there are many (any cichlid like polleni or other robust fish that attain a size of around 10" or more), that will dislodge plants by simply moving around.
At present I have a very densely planted tank with Andinoacara coerleopunctatus, these cichlids are considered in most literature, to be plant compatible, yet every morning, there are dislodged plants floating around the tank, even though the largest of these cichlids is only 5".
In aquariums by serious aquatic gardeners like the "Amano" enthusiasts, you hardly every see any fish, much larger than a small tetra, because those small species are the best the way to maintain those beautiful type aquascapes.
With most of my large cichlids (when in the states) I used separate planted refugiums, or separate tanks connected to cichlid tanks by plumbing, that didn't contain any cichlids in them to provide the planted displays I like, and the benefits that those planted tanks provide for water quality. I do find planted tanks, as interesting in themselves, as cichlid tanks, but in most cases find large cichlids, and plants to be incompatible.
For those tanks, I kept Killifish, small wild type Bettas, juvie grow out cichlids, or those species I knew would be plant friendly.
 
Just as a general rule (maybe even an absolute) because they are primarily vegetarian, some cichlids that should never be considered for a planted tank. One to fit this section of MFK, the Indian species
Etroplus suratensus.
Etroplus eating dandilions
There are 2 Central Americans, that are primarily vegetarian,
Cincilichthys pearsei, and C. bocourti

My bocourti even ate Papayrus (which is essentially paper)
The south American Uaru amphiacanthoides.
Others that are at least 50% vegetarian, and normally not good candidates for a planted tank, are from the genus Vieja.
I leave any Africans vegetarian advice to the expert African keepers.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
MonsterFishKeepers.com