Pike personality?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

qtrhorse89

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jul 13, 2009
219
1
0
North Carolina
After the recent death of my beloved 1 yr old fahaka due to a feeding strike he just never recovered from I find myself with an empty 120 gallon. Frankly, I was too attached to my buddy Ratchet and I just can't see me getting another fahaka anytime soon, looking at pics of other fahakas makes me want to cry. So, I've been looking around and the pikes have caught my eye.

My questions is how is their personality in general. I'd like something on the hardy side, my pH is around 6.8 so no hard water issues. But, more importantly I'm after a fish that will "bond" with its owner. In other words if I come up to the tank I'd rather it not dart into hiding. I'd prefer for it to come meet me at the glass. IDK maybe i'm spoiled by the puffers but are there any of you out there with pikes who behave like this. Can you hand feed them or would you even want to? Which species if any are the most personable or is it a matter of personal opinion. I'm not very interested in the dwarf species and I would probably only want to keep one crenicichla rather than multiple specimens.

Ratchet was my only large fish and he was my baby, so the pike will end up getting spoiled and would most definitely be the star of the tank, but it would be nice to have more than one fish. (The only complaint I'll ever have about fahakas) Is there anything that they would get along with well. I see others have used geophagus which are interesting fish, but what else would you all suggest?

Thanks,
Kim

P.S. I understand that any new fish is going to take a while to settle in. These questions are obviously meant for after the fish has acclimated to its new environment.
 
try looking at the species of pike called the
2 spotted pike cichlid
i have 2 and they always greet me at the glass and ARNT scared of me what so ever
i also have a geophagus with them as well as lots of other species
a diff direction you ever consider a giant gourami??
 
I'll look into the pike cichlid you mentioned. I was under the impression that a giant gourami would grow much too large to be housed in my 120?
 
id have to say from my opinion 120 gallon tank would be sufficient enough for 1 giant gourami
i have a baby as of now prolly 8 inches
with alot of other fish i have no aggresion no stress issues amoung fish
they are great thou look at my pics of my tank
 
the most personable pike I have is my cincta. she comes to the front everytime I walk by and will just hang out as long as I am there. My vennie was that way too.
 
My pikes are all pretty mellow. I only see them fight anything if a bichir tryies to pull half swallowed food out of their mouths. My lugburis pikes are still small though. The saxtilis is sexually mature.

all 3 will dart to the front when they see me coming, and they will all take krill and shrimp from my hands
 
my sveni and punctata were very personable almost more than any other cichlid that i've had. i raised them from about 3" up to 6". my belly crawlers are still pretty shy. i've had them about a month and they like to hid under wood and in plants. the male is starting to come around. if you do decide to go with pikes, get a group of young ones and grow them out, heck you may get them to spawn in a 120g. i'd go with lents or a sax species
 
HiImSean;4200905; said:
my sveni and punctata were very personable almost more than any other cichlid that i've had. i raised them from about 3" up to 6". my belly crawlers are still pretty shy. i've had them about a month and they like to hid under wood and in plants. the male is starting to come around. if you do decide to go with pikes, get a group of young ones and grow them out, heck you may get them to spawn in a 120g. i'd go with lents or a sax species

ive noticed that with almost all the belly crawlers ive seen. always pretty shy.

i think most saxatilis and lugubris species will work fine. im more of a lugubris species fan so id recommend:
johannas
marmorata
cincta
lenticulata

i think all of those make a nice centerpiece for the tank and i love geo's as an additive to the tank.
 
I agree with Obsession... + My 12" Johanna and 12" Lenticulata both come up to the front of the glass when they see me. My larger johanna is probably my favorite fish, personality wise, and most people that see my tanks like him most.
 
Thanks guys for all the replies. Right now it's probably down to the lenticulata or johanna. Both have nice adult colors to me. It will probably come down to availability. Tank mates are still up in the air. I think I will really enjoy having a pike.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com