Your P's might nip each other for the duration of their lives. @ 3-5" they are juvi to sub-adult - it proabably has more to do with the pecking order than lack of food or space for the time being. RBP's will instinctively thin their numbers if the food supply is to small, not enough space, or poor health within the shoal. The nutrional value of feeder goldfish is definately in the negative, a tank full of zero is still zero - just an uneducated reponse from a bussiness man.