Porous coral tips. help!

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
there are so many things that may or may not be affecting the coral that you just have to try to touch every possibility and eliminate one after the other till you find or get what you suspect is the culprit.

mr.reef24
 
ne cichlids, youre referring to a different scale, i'm using meq/l, our values are comparable.
unless the hydno can release toxins i know thats not it cause corals well out of range are suffering and i watch my tank alot and have never seen the flame even think about it, and the appearance of the coral doesn't look at all like nips.

mr. reef, yeah, thats the only choice i figured i had, i started that a couple days ago and it looks to be improving, but it may just be in my head.

now my colt coral is shrinking! i thought maybe its just not fully inflated but the areas where its attached to the rock are actually retracting back, what the he11, its been like this for three days now.
think i would have more luck if i started an account on reef central?
do you think too much of something could cause this?
 
hmmm. I would stay clear of reefcentral.com they have good members BUT double the false information and weird rules. Do you currently use activated carbon in the system alot of times this can pull out chemicals that soft corals use in chemical war fare with other corals especially if it is over crowded.

mr.reef24
 
i don't think my tank is overcrowded but maybe, and i regularly frag my xenias. if i can find some carbon around i will do that, thanks.

i asked my local fish store guy and he seems to think 20k metal halide is no good so i switched back to my 14k, i'll see if that does anything, or everything will bleach :( we'll see.
 
the bulb is about 6-8" from the water and the digitata is another 6-8 below that. it is a 250w odysea, which i think are actually about 200 watts. it was doing very well at one point, thats why i don't think that would be the issue. i was watching for a really long time today and i saw the flame angel nip at one of the tips, i only saw him do it once and the areas that would be very inconvenient for him to get at are still like the rest, so not sure if thats it either.
i'll watch more and keep a close eye on all the corals.

the lfs guy's opinion was that 10-15k bulbs are much much better for growth and 20k are really only used for color and that there will be very little growth under them. what do you think?
 
Here are some tips,
Alk and Ca, along with Mg needs to be as constant as possible.
If your 20K lamps are less than 10 months old, hold off on buying new bulbs and purchase a Ca reactor instead.

The Ca reactor will stabilize your Ca/Alk/Mg uptake and will immediately improve your SPS colonies.

The Hydno can cause problems, but I doubt it has anything to do with your growth problem. It is related to one of two things. Either you are exhausting available Ca and trace elements, or you have a higher level of PO4 than you realize. (Only a Photometer will give you a accurate reading)

Your corals have good color, so PO4 is probably not the issue as it would brown out so the addition of a Ca reactor should help immensely.

As lighting goes, 10K bulbs have shown to be the best for rapid growth, however color may suffer compared to 20K bulbs. 20K tend to fluoresce corals more and make the colors stand out more. If you are interested in rapid growth for frags, I suggest the 10K's, if you want good colar and nice display, I suggest the staying with 20K's. If your bulbs are older than 10 months change them.

Flow is very underestimated. By adding some high volume powerheads like Koralia 4 you can increase flow and in turn stimulate growth. If you already have these powerheads, you can move them around to create a new flow pattern that will also stimulate the coral's growth.

Most importantly, make sure you are doing regular water changes. If there is a water parameter problem this will help to fix it.

Also, if you do change the bulbs, remember to light acclimate your tank by raising the lamps for the first 2 weeks or use a shorter photoperiod so that you do not bleach your corals. :)
~Rich
 
i have began feeding about five times a day to help curb the !@#$%^& flame angels curiosity and doing 10% weekly water changes. i think its fixed! in a couple more weeks i will do maybe 5% / week. i also switched from coral vite to reef fuel about a week ago to see what happens.
thanks alot guys for all the help. i will post any progress
 
flame angel could be nipping the corals, if you add carbon in the tank it should remove some of the chemicals corals use to fight one another. Anything different lately with the corals any updates?

mr.reef24
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com