Proportionally equal aquariums?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Money
It is more of the opposite
Say a 1" fish gets a tank 16-24x its length to pace around and explore. Now scale that up to a 24-30" fish. Now by that logic, you'd be giving that fish a tank the size of (or bigger than) a bus. See why people only give big fish space to pace 3-4 times?
Seems immoral to be picking and choosing just because of money restraints. Imo everything about keeping animals in captivity is different, no predators, food all the time, and small enclosures for most. I don’t think it’s bad or good it’s just different.
 
Even without predators, with daily feedings, none of the dangers of nature,...... yet......, the disease section is filled with problems.
I believe putting large fish in what really constitutes to a puddle, or a rut in the road, mostly due to financial or special concerns, should be taken into account by all well meaning fish keepers.
To me putting an oscar in anything under 100 gallons, is like putting it in a puddle, or just as bad putting it in improper water conditions, which often goes hand in hand with being stuffed in a puddle.
Even putting an oscar (or any large cichlid) in 200 gallons, is like putting it in a culvert of a drive way.

What species would you confortably or realistically find in such a limited amount space?
At best, maybe some killifish, a few mosquito fish, minnows. But an oscar, an arowana, a pacu or stingray?
Recently here on MFK there was a post wondering about fish getting sad in a small space, seems to me they usually express that "sadness" quite obviously.... either they kill there neighbors, or get a disease or just plain kick the bucket.
 
Last edited:
Problem is we are human, and as such have the ability to decide what is right and wrong……….. and hence we decide that that in itself is a right we have…….. to decide.
All comes down to conscience really.
Are you ok with an Oscar in 100g
Do you want your Oscar in 200g
Or do you feel your Oscar should be in 1000g
Or do you feel your Oscar should be left in the wild.
Up to you
Or should I really have said, what are you happy with other people thinking of you!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com