Question about salt

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
Normal table salt has iodine in it and should never be used in an aquarium. Sea salt is normally fine as is any non-iodized salt.
 
bigspizz;1039609; said:


In learning about raw feeding our dogs and natural diets for the rest of our animals we learned to watch for certain things..

the first, and IMO most important, is advice from someone that sells products that do the same thing that you want to do naturally.

when you read a sales pitch you need to learn to tell the difference between carefully crafted crap and real info that you can use.
 
bigspizz;1039574; said:
Epsom salt is synonymous(same as) with aquarium salt...1 tablespoon of whatever salt per 5 gallons.

Some fish, or aquarium pets are sensitive to salt. So read up. "Iodized" table salt is BAD, non iodized can be used the same as others.

Iodized will be labeled boldly, but just read all the words and compare the two at the store and you will easily see the difference.

Salt is a fix all so to speak, and a good alternative to many chems and meds.

It promotes fin regeneration, slime coat, soothes the gills in times of high stress or after allot of particles get stirred up in the tank.

I could probubly start a chain of links with differing opinions that would last a good month but I'd rather use your own post...

If I'm wrong..as you say...then what does that say about your own previous post?
 
Wolf3101;1039626; said:
I could probubly start a chain of links with differing opinions that would last a good month but I'd rather use your own post...

If I'm wrong..as you say...then what does that say about your own previous post?




No no "wrong" (and I did say sorry and sir in all seriousness) was that there was no such thing as "UN" iodized table salt. There are two different types iodized and unionized. Not trying to fight just saying what I know.
 
Morledzep;1039618; said:
In learning about raw feeding our dogs and natural diets for the rest of our animals we learned to watch for certain things..

the first, and IMO most important, is advice from someone that sells products that do the same thing that you want to do naturally.

when you read a sales pitch you need to learn to tell the difference between carefully crafted crap and real info that you can use.


What were they selling? themselves as accredited researchers?


http://aquascienceresearch.com/About.htm



All of that stuff was new to me also In the above post I explain the confusion. No matter what that link says I would personally NOT put iodized in my tanks I have been warned against it many many times, and all my cichlid books say never use it. It could be crap, we all can decide that, categorically, or collectively, or leave it be, in either case, The above post explains my only view on this topic. Hope things are more clear now.



And still just asking. what was second? The bold sentence to me is an incomplete thought and I have read it 50 times....
 
I buy "uniodized" salt at the local supermarket for .60 cents for a pint or so and it works just fine. I really don't think there is a difference between this and the stuff prepared for aquariums other than the price. In my opinion, sodium chloride is sodium chloride no matter how you label it. I have read that table salt has anti clumping agents added, but doesn't seem to hurt anything.
 
That HAS to be one of the most hottly debated topics in the fish world judging from some of the websites I've seen on line about it. I think I'll stick with the party line and just recomend 'aquarium' salt...LOL
 
Wolf3101;1040366; said:
That HAS to be one of the most hottly debated topics in the fish world judging from some of the websites I've seen on line about it. I think I'll stick with the party line and just recomend 'aquarium' salt...LOL





Very "debated".....just like activated carbon and hole in the head. I use auarium salt from walmart as stated before it is CHEAP!!!:)
 
if you are just using salt with the 1 per 5 rule then table salt is fine because there is very little iodine in the salt as iodine is very toxic to humans but I wouldnt recommend using table salt for brackish tanks as brackish tanks are normally higher then the 1 per 5...
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com