Rare Myanmar species

[skareb]

Banjar red, 1.5 red, tongyang, all the same thing...its just a red crossed with a green...when something crosses with something else it = hybrid, get it?

Grand master, if we cross a Red aro and a green aro we get banjar red is this what you're preaching?

 

[ronnie08]

whether its photo shop or not, i love it..

i can assure you that the batik aro really do exist..took these photo's when i was in malaysia a couple of week's ago tell you what photo's doesnt do this fish any justice! please do take a drive to xian leng in shah alam it is worth the effort...

 

[jlnguyen74]

i can assure you that the batik aro really do exist..took these photo's when i was in malaysia a couple of week's ago tell you what photo's doesnt do this fish any justice! please do take a drive to xian leng in shah alam it is worth the effort...

No one say batik aro doesn't exist. It was said batik aro is a variety of green arowana.

 

[ronnie08]

No one say batik aro doesn't exist. It was said batik aro is a variety of green arowana.

sorry didnt read the whole thread...either way it's a damm nice fish.

 

[skareb]

No one say batik aro doesn't exist. It was said batik aro is a variety of green arowana.

No one say it is or not a variety of green, I'm saying it doesnt look like green, and I'm very curious in which angle you look at it that it look like green to you.

But you're the master, who knows so much about arowana so most probably you're right...btw care to answer me where banjar red come from? lfs?

 

[jlnguyen74]

Grand master, can you answer me a point blank question, do banjar red exist in the wild? timeline is not important my question is: banjar red come from nature or man made? Because your second master says banjar red are man made, so I'm wondering where is your stand on this.

Take your time and read! If you have comprehensive problem, take a reading comprehensive class. If you can't understand, it's your problem. Don't put words in people's mouth. Banjar red is hybrid. That doesn't mean it's man made only. That doesn't mean it doesn't exist in the wild. I don't think arowana discrimate against their color. If a male meets a female arowana, whether in a river, a pond, or an aquarium, and they like each other, they mate, and have fries! There is no study on Banjar red to confirm of their locality. It was only told that Banjar red originated from the southern tip of Indonesia, but then, it was only told.

 

[jlnguyen74]

sorry didnt read the whole thread...either way it's a damm nice fish.

Totally agree!

 

[jlnguyen74]

No one say it is or not a variety of green, I'm saying it doesnt look like green, and I'm very curious in which angle you look at it that it look like green to you.

Just like "it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, but it's not a duck!"

 

[skareb]

There was an "asian aro keeper" once said that black arowana is just silver arowana that was born under different water parameter, so I was not quite surprise to see another "asian aro keeper" who thinks Banjar Red is NOT hybrid Probably Bajar Red is Red arowana that were born in Banjar river, or Banjar city, or Banjar farm!

Take your time and read! If you have comprehensive problem, take a reading comprehensive class. If you can't understand, it's your problem. Don't put words in people's mouth. Banjar red is hybrid. That doesn't mean it's man made only. That doesn't mean it doesn't exist in the wild. I don't think arowana discrimate against their color. If a male meets a female arowana, whether in a river, a pond, or an aquarium, and they like each other, they mate, and have fries! There is no study on Banjar red to confirm of their locality. It was only told that Banjar red originated from the southern tip of Indonesia, but then, it was only told.

May I ask what do you mean by hybrid?
If we cross a red and green do we get banjar red?
Or do you really mean banjar red is a close relative of green?

your grand master dare not answer me this perhaps you will

 

[skareb]

Just like "it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, but it's not a duck!"

for a person who never seen the real fish with yours own eyes sure talks a lot, question is what you saying is it even relevant