rbps and gar, bad Idea?

[kevbc03]

yeah....better dispose of the idea, the gar would be gone.

 

[John Rambo]

yeah....better dispose of the idea, the gar would be gone.

lol, if I post this in the gar section they would say the rbps would be gone. I agree with them. If any fish gets eaten. it would be a 4" rbp, not a 18-20" alligator gar.

 

[JoeDizzleMPLS]

lol, if I post this in the gar section they would say the rbps would be gone. I agree with them. If any fish gets eaten. it would be a 4" rbp, not a 18-20" alligator gar.

i think the gar would suffer some fin nips and could get beaten up and eaten over time, but it would definitely try eating the piranhas, so the piranhas may never get the chance...

 

[keepinfish]

lol, if I post this in the gar section they would say the rbps would be gone. I agree with them. If any fish gets eaten. it would be a 4" rbp, not a 18-20" alligator gar.

i doubt it, rbp will eat any tankmates.

 

[Armand]

i think the gar would suffer some fin nips and could get beaten up and eaten over time, but it would definitely try eating the piranhas, so the piranhas may never get the chance...

Yeah, it really depends on the size of the fish, in this case being the gar much more bigger than RBP' the most probably to happen is gar eating RBP.

 

[peter the graetfish]

ITS A OK IDEA F UR P'S ARE BIG BUT IF NOT THE GAR IN SOME HUNGRY SICTHUATIONS WILL TRY AND EAT. IF U HAVE A GOOD STRONG SHOAL AND DONT FEED UR P'S THEY WILL EAT UR GAR.