Red devil vs Asian arowana?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

arowana

Candiru
MFK Member
Apr 25, 2005
150
1
46
50
The Netherlands
Hi, I have a 20-25 inch red asian arowana and I have the opportunity to buy a red devil breedingpair from 10-12 inch. I freally love Red devils, but would this be a safe buy?
 
You would need a large tank. Generally would not be a problem when not breeding, but if they a guarding fry and in tight quarters you will have a problem. Since the Arow stays near the top it does not compete directly for space.

I have had Arows and devils in tanks 300 gallons or more with no problems even when they bred and raised the fry.
 
FishInABowl;4400061; said:
You would need a large tank. Generally would not be a problem when not breeding, but if they a guarding fry and in tight quarters you will have a problem. Since the Arow stays near the top it does not compete directly for space.

I have had Arows and devils in tanks 300 gallons or more with no problems even when they bred and raised the fry.

My tank is 330 gallon (1250 liter). The Red devil pair has fry at the moment, so the change of getting new fry is high.

Also in the tank:
2 x polypterys bichir bichir (20 inch)
Gar (20 inch)
H. Odoe (10 inch)
Datnioides (10 inch)
Fire eel (20 inch)
4 x Panaque (12 inch)
.......and lots of wood. Is there any risk putting this RD pair in to the tank???????
 
I think it's a toss-up. Some RD pairs are so aggressive when spawning that they won't tolerate anything near them. Because aros are slower moving, I'd be afraid for its safety. Then again, it's a 330g so you might be ok. How densely is the wood decorated in there? You might be able to get away with it if the RD pair have a spot they feel secure in.
 
arowana;4402424; said:
Thanks all for the advice. I want to avoid a lot of stress in the tank, so I decided to play safe and will not buy them.

Probably wisest. We all know how tempting it can be !
 
Bummer - I think the 2 Bichirs would've raided the nest eliminating most if not all of the fry thus controlling the RD's aggresion - Might sound crazy however I've seen it 1st hand with Bichirs and breeding cichlids. The Cichlids are at their most aggressive state when the fry start free-swimming.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com