Redtail Cat.. What did my wife get me into?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
I'm going to go against the grain here and say that most people like to greatly exaggerate the size of a red tail catfish. It won't hit 6 feet, it probably won't even hit four feet. If someone can show me a verified picture of a four foot plus red tail in an aquarium/pond then I'll eat my words, until then, I think around 40 inches is a more realistic expectation but it will take several years to reach that size as they slow down greatly around 30 inches.

If you reallllyyyy want to keep him it doesn't have to cost $100,000 either. I'm not sure where that number came from. A 600 gallon stock tank will run a few hundred dollars and will hold him for a long time with its 8 ft diameter. The only issue is they don't fit in many doorways. http://www.plastic-mart.com/product/105/610-gallon-green-poly-round-stock-tank-arm-10139

For filtration, turn a fifty gallon drum into a sand filter(non fluidized bed), pick up a decent submersible pump and you're good to go. You can put the heaters inside the drum to keep them out of the pond.

Between the tank($300), pump ($200), heaters ($60) and sand/pvc($40) you're looking at around $600 for a six hundred gallon pond that you don't have to build and will keep him happy for a long time.

As for food, yes they eat alot but it doesn't have to be expensive. Catfish chow is $20 for fifty pounds and there are plenty of cheap fish if you know where to look. hint, its not tilapia. Plus, if you fish there is another option, no need to filet the catch either, just chunk it up and throw it in the freezer for a few weeks to kill of anything before feeding.

Sorry to derail, I don't believe that they should be in the pet trade but for all those already out there, there are ways to keep them happy without spending an arm and a leg. With that in mind, all my big cats were given to me for free but I wouldn't trade them for anything. There is nothing quite like a sea of giant mouths snapping that surface to greet you..err beg for food;)
 
Good post. I agree, DIY-ers and survivors can make due with little.

The number I so "freely" threw out there is for their lifetime, which I also estimated at 30 years, out of which 25 years are adulthood at 4' size or so. The bulk of the estimate is the cost of the swimming pool construction and the cost of heating it in a temperate climate for that many years. Surely, things vary for different keepers and different climates.

IMHO, RTC will outgrow the 600 stock pond in the first 1.5-2 years of its life but this view varies greaty too (except among experts and high level aficionados).

I also catch food for my guys too, doing exactly the same thing - chopping up and freezing to kill parasites. The $20 per 50lb bag foods are excellent for large natural water bodies, IMO, where it is not the only food option and where more excreeted waste matters little or rather not at all.

Anyway, I don't think we are disagreeing much, just discussin' :) for OP's sake, who went somewhere behind the scenes, it seems... :)
 
Lol no worries. I know how well you know your catfish/big fish in general. It was more intended for those who haven't really considered much outside of a glass fish tank and pellets from the pet store, something that just doesn't cut it for these fish.

Also, although it is likely obvious at this point, i'm a huge fan of the stock tanks for cost, convenience and durability. Also the dimensions of a 300 gallon stock tank are imo much better than a regular 8 ft tank. I personally feel like a RTC would be fine in a 600 gallon tank for a bit longer than 2 years but there is no denying that bigger is better. I'm no expert though, merely another hobbyist who enjoys his catfish...besides, I'm not young enough to know everything:)
 
And yes, I proudly consider myself to be the epitome of a DIY/survivor. If I ever win the lottery then I'll gladly change my ways.

As for the op, he is probably taking the fish back the store after reading this thread.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com