RES with pictus catfish

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Will the spike kill my turtle or injure it if she eats it


  • Total voters
    28
  • Poll closed .
There are so many catfish species many of which are common and stay small...i'm sure there is a safer alternative. But the fact that they hang around the bottom may make it easier for the turtle to catch them in the first place.
 
krzr3000;4601518; said:
There are so many catfish species many of which are common and stay small...i'm sure there is a safer alternative. But the fact that they hang around the bottom may make it easier for the turtle to catch them in the first place.

Any recommendation? Besides pleco and algae eater. Preferbly a catfish with whiskers. My turtle is too lazy to catch fish besides as long as she is safe i dont mind.
 
Honestly i dont think it would happen as a turtle tend to eat a fish in peices, not in 1 chunk. Unless the fish is that small comapred to the turtle. I wouldnt do it either way though. I could see the guy spike him though if the turt tries but i dont think that would stop the turtle from eating it.

zenyoungkoh;4601521; said:
Any recommendation? Besides pleco and algae eater. Preferbly a catfish with whiskers. My turtle is too lazy to catch fish besides as long as she is safe i dont mind.

NEVER underestimate a turtle, i have seen very small turtle kill a larger fish no problem just by biting chunks from there skin. A turtle will get off its lazy but when it wants to, trust me.
 
Why risk it? I doubt many people voting for "no" will actually have kept pictus with a turtle anyway?

Any fish you put with a turtle should be expected to be feeders. A pictus is an expensive, and poor choice as a feeder, so I don't recommend keeping it with the turtle, because even if you think it won't become one, it probably will.

Paul
 
My turtle lived with fish all its live before it started living with me. Gave it a bigger tank and now he eats fish, so he no longer has any friends in the tank. i would no suggest keeping any fish with a turtle unless you are okay with them dying.

Do you have a larger tank set up since your female turtle should be heading to a larger tank soon depending on your tank measurements.
 
I kept Pictus with turtles for almost 2 years and never had issues. The turtles didnt even pay attention to them.
 
RES don't do well with any fish, not to mention a female RES will need a 5'x2' enclosure as an adult plus a basking area and UV light. RES are not made to live in fish tanks.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com