rhomb or rbp's?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
that is very on topic, you said that you were informed that you would be getting a rhom that can fit in a 20 gallon for life, if that's the case, you were misinformed
 
yes i was thanks for the info
im thinkin more on the black rhom side
what rhom do you suggest for a 20 growout? or 55?
 
all types of rhoms are the same species so they will be the same in most aspects, but will vary in appearance due to collection point. a small 2 inch rhom would be fine in a 20 for awhile, but you'll have to move him to a 55 after a bit, where he would be fine for many years, any small rhom that you get will top off around the 10 inch mark. if you were looking at another type of serra species, your options would really open up.
 
koop171;1570856; said:
don't rhoms grow really really slow after like 6or 7"
yeah, if you buy a small rhom, it'll grow fast up until about 6" then it will slow down and top off around 10". growing rhoms past 10" maybe 12" tops just doesn't happen in captivity.
 
i think it will actually be more important to figure out how much you're gonna be willing to spend up front. if you wanna keep things cheap up front, go with a shoal of reds and you'll be happy. if you wanna spend a bit more, go with a mixed shoal and you'll be happy. if you wanna spend a few hundred up front, buy a large rhom and you'll be happy. that is the advice that i would give for stocking the 125... obviously if you get small pygos, you can start them out in the smaller tanks, but if you wanna really fill that 125 eventually, buying a small rhom is probably not what you wanna do because you said you already had concerns about having only one smaller fish in a huge tank. if you have your heart set on a large rhom, you're gonna have to spend the dough up front to get it, don't have false hopes about raising a little 2" rhom up to a 16" monster, cuz it ain't gonna happen.
 
JoeDizzleMPLS;1573230; said:
i think it will actually be more important to figure out how much you're gonna be willing to spend up front. if you wanna keep things cheap up front, go with a shoal of reds and you'll be happy. if you wanna spend a bit more, go with a mixed shoal and you'll be happy. if you wanna spend a few hundred up front, buy a large rhom and you'll be happy. that is the advice that i would give for stocking the 125... obviously if you get small pygos, you can start them out in the smaller tanks, but if you wanna really fill that 125 eventually, buying a small rhom is probably not what you wanna do because you said you already had concerns about having only one smaller fish in a huge tank. if you have your heart set on a large rhom, you're gonna have to spend the dough up front to get it, don't have false hopes about raising a little 2" rhom up to a 16" monster, cuz it ain't gonna happen.
im going to have to disagree
people can do anything
and im a very responsible person
and im looking for one around 5 to 6 inches
 
Both! 2 tanks!
 
dzb912;1575562; said:
im going to have to disagree
people can do anything
and im a very responsible person
and im looking for one around 5 to 6 inches
you can disagree all you want, but that doesn't change the fact that you're not gonna grow a 5 or 6 inch rhom past 10-12". rhoms don't reach those lengths in captivity, it has been tried many times by many responsible keepers. check out opefe for more info on that.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com