Theres isn't any hard feelings,we all wouldn't be men if we didn't have our own opinions on building things.Controversy always makes for a good conversation-we just need beer now.

Like I said,who knows?I could be wrong or right.........It's always a good thing to discover new products at cheaper costs that are reliable.I openly admit,I didn't see that this product had no form of tar in it but I do know that 99% of roofing products do have tar,which is partly oil and chemicals as previously stated.If it is totally non toxic and safe to use then I would support its use.BUT-I still say who knows how long it will last?I know that he said he used it for 4 years without issue and thats great but will it last another 4 years or ten years etc?I just know that when I build my gargantuan tank that I will want something that gives me no problems for my life time.