Rubberlip vs. Bristlenose Pleco

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
L021;4520884; said:
What tank are they going in? In your 10g/future45g stock, either would be good, I'd only really recommend a BN if it's with bichirs, and a jag would swallow either of those whole.

I had my bristlenose back when I had a 14" Jag, had another with my 15" Dovii and it was fine. Just try to get a BN that's a little bigger. My BN's were about 5" back then and were totally ignored by the Parachromis.
 
I have a rubbernose pleco in with my jags and it's fine. The Jags never pay it any attention. I have been curious about the BN pleco though. My rubbernose kicks butt on the algea, it eats like no other creature I've ever seen.
 
Dullamite;4521281; said:
I have been curious about the BN pleco though. My rubbernose kicks butt on the algea, it eats like no other creature I've ever seen.

I think they're about equivalent in that dept.
 
i have kept both in equal sized tanks at the same time, while they where equally sized. the tanks where both spotless, the only dif seems to be appearance and the fact that the rubbernose/lip takes 2x as long to grow in my experiences with them. good luck either is awesome.
 
NCStateFisher;4520283; said:
I know that I don't want to get a common pleco because they get too big and make too much mess, but of these 2 options which do you think are better cleaners? I think rubber's get approx 10" and bristles get 6" correct? any input would be appreciated.
Bristles get to about 6", rubbers rarely pass the 5" mark.

which do you think are better cleaners?
Neither, both will just make your tank much dirtier than it already is. Plus, the addition of either of them would also mean that that's one more type of food you have to buy and use regularly.
 
Rubbernose tend to be more aggressive with other bottom dwellers imo. Me I prefer an albino bushynose. Both will get around 6 inches.
 
hmmm... may not even bother getting one as much waste as they produce lol, thanks for the input though guys
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com