You are both incorrect. I know the laws very well. The permit required is a Scientific Collecting Permit, it costs about $50 and is renewed every 2 yrs. they are issued to museums, universities, school teachers, etc. it covers everyone working with or assisting the permit holder. once the fish are collected under the permit they can be kept in private aquariums by anyone.
That is not the case with these fish. I got them when buying some split tails at the bait shop, happens quite often. Bait suppliers require different permits, but again it only really covers collection. these fish were collected legally, and therefore legal to keep.
Thanks for not jumping to conclusions, youve been most helpful.
I have positively ID'd these fish as pikeminnows based on their abundance in local waterways and some pictures I found through DFG of juveniles.