I still say if you have all his info., go down to his house, confront him face to face, and you'll either
A. Get your fish
B. Get to see some spineless PoS squirm b/c you're there to get your money back or whip him a good one
I'd mapquest it and double check to make sure everything, including whoever this guy is, actually exists.
EDIT: I see you live in texas...that sucks, I didn't realize you were that far away...pay me $100 and I'll go to his house, he can't live that far away from me >
That or just nag him constantly until he breaks, or threaten with a lawsuit, attorney, that sorta thing.
A. Get your fish
B. Get to see some spineless PoS squirm b/c you're there to get your money back or whip him a good one

I'd mapquest it and double check to make sure everything, including whoever this guy is, actually exists.
EDIT: I see you live in texas...that sucks, I didn't realize you were that far away...pay me $100 and I'll go to his house, he can't live that far away from me >
That or just nag him constantly until he breaks, or threaten with a lawsuit, attorney, that sorta thing.