Scrubbies vs Bio Balls

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Steve_Henderson

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jun 24, 2008
42
0
0
New Jersey
Just a quick question on what most people prefer to use. I've read that the idea is they have the near same surface area, however, everyone rants about how cheap scrubbies are and I can't find them cheap! Cost me around $15 for 18 of the scrubbies at walmart, and it seems that most dollar stores around here don't carry them for some weird reason. I looked on drs. foster and smith and found a gallon of bio balls for 7$, or a 5 gallon bucket for 28$. In this case, wouldn't bio balls prove to be more efficient and cost effective? Just looking for opinions, thanks!
 
bio balls are inferior to scrubbies, both in cost and surface area. see here http://www.wernersponds.com/biofiltermedia.htm

have you checked Big Lots? i couldnt find any dollar stores around me that had them, but Big Lots did. $1.50 for 6, the Brawny brand
 
Do you have dollar generals? Thats where I bought mine at. 6 scrubbies for $1. I started off buying them at walmart as well but $2.50 for 4 was not cutting it.
 
I buy mines from H.E.B $1.59 for 3
 
I just ordered 400 of them for $62 from doitbest.com as long as you have a local store that allows shipments their is no shipping or tax.
 
Anyone got a guesstimate as to how many you'd need for say a fx5 or for a smallish sump? Like a rough guess as to # of scrubbies per cu ft or something would be very helpful.
 
i got 12 per tray in my FX5, 36 in total
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com