Should I keep this one?

[Steve p]

The white one with the red markings always seem to be out to kill ,the older they get the meaner ,but it is a good looker. I just know it will tear up the other fish in your tank.

Mine is a mean bugger and seams to get meaner as time goes on, As for yours its a keeper IMO

 

[AttackFish]

Nah... I dont think you should.

Pretty sure you should give it to me...

 

[jackel]

great loon devil, deff. keep.

 

[Opiate]

up to u mate...

 

[fwlion]

RD's CHANGE so much between 1.5-8in. its ridiculus all you can do and keep until then and then make you decision they beautiful creamsicle baby devil is liable to turn just a straight average everyday uniform orange color

but i would keep until at least 7-8in. and then make your decision

 

[ScullCraca]

I would keep it! But it's Probably going to be a BIG Agro! At adult hood. Got any empty extra tanks!

 

[greenterra]

The white one with the red markings always seem to be out to kill ,the older they get the meaner ,but it is a good looker. I just know it will tear up the other fish in your tank.

Well that would depend on the other fish in the tank and also the RD's temperament.Some mellow out as they age.Speculation on whether or not it will be a killer at this time or a judgement of temperament by colour is just useless IMO.

As for the fish in question,I think it looks great and shows potential.Personally I love the white look.

 

[Gourami Swami]

He looks awesome Keep him and put him in his own 75g or the Tankmates are toast!

 

[bigspizz]

Thanks guys! I sure wish I had a WHOLE bunch of tanks....Oh wait...I do.... My power bill is 350+ a month to give you all an idea. Thanks for the input, and tank space is not the issue here. I just wanted to know if anyone else thought the first O and W was a keeper for sure. I think he is one of the nicest Rd's I have ever had. His markings are all in the right spots and his tail is one of a kind Again thanks guys

 

[dlp40]

Keeper.